SmoothWall UTM-1000 review
Smoothwall’s latest all-in-one security appliance is a top performer but not so easy to install and configure.
We found the SmoothGuard could be frustrating during deployment and configuration but capable of delivering excellent results for anti-spam and web filtering. It looks good value as well with a wide range of security features for the price.

For IM apps you can enable the appliance to proxy this traffic on specific interfaces where it can block file transfers. Smoothwall's Message Censor can also be configured with rules to look for inappropriate content and words in IM messages and replace them.
Smoothwall offers both transparent and non-transparent modes for web filtering but client systems must be configured to use the appliance as a proxy regardless of your choice. If you want to apply user authentication and rule based access policies then non-transparent mode in the one to go for. With this in action you can pick and choose from the appliance's local user and group database or external RADIUS, AD and LDAP servers.
The MailShell anti-spam feature proved to be extremely effective and we tested this over a seven day period where it scanned live email coming into the lab. We asked it to tag any dodgy messages so we could use rules in our Outlook mail client to move them to a separate folder. At the end of the test we found MailShell had scored a perfect 100 per cent success rate as nothing slipped through its net, whilst false positives were down at only three per cent.
For web content filtering you can create various access policies and apply them either to different groups of users, or for everyone and use time schedules to determine when they are active. Guardian is very versatile as it offers 24 main URL categories, under which are a further 72 sub-categories. Guardian also supports phrase checking within web page content but we did find that general policy creation wasn't easy and the proxy had to be restarted every time we made any changes.
Nevertheless, Guardian performed well during testing as all our attempts to visit online gambling sites were firmly blocked using the preconfigured content filtering policies. Social networking sites are now a major concern for businesses and we were able to create a new policy for these, which blocked access to sites such as MySpace and Facebook. A safe search option is also provided where the results of web searches will be checked and access blocked where appropriate.
The SmoothGuard 1000-UTM delivers a choice selection of security measures for the price all packaged into a well specified appliance. We weren't impressed with problems experienced during installation and found the web interface unintuitive but Smoothwall certainly made up for this with a fine performance in our web filtering and anti-spam tests.
Verdict
We found the SmoothGuard could be frustrating during deployment and configuration but capable of delivering excellent results for anti-spam and web filtering. It looks good value as well with a wide range of security features for the price.
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
Chassis: 1U rack chassis CPU: 2.12GHz Intel Core 2 Duo Memory: 2GB 667MHz DDR2 Storage: 120GB Hitachi 2.5in SFF SATA hard disk Network: 7 x Gigabit Ethernet Management: Web browser
Dave is an IT consultant and freelance journalist specialising in hands-on reviews of computer networking products covering all market sectors from small businesses to enterprises. Founder of Binary Testing Ltd – the UK’s premier independent network testing laboratory - Dave has over 45 years of experience in the IT industry.
Dave has produced many thousands of in-depth business networking product reviews from his lab which have been reproduced globally. Writing for ITPro and its sister title, PC Pro, he covers all areas of business IT infrastructure, including servers, storage, network security, data protection, cloud, infrastructure and services.
-
Nearly 700,000 customers impacted after insider attack at US fintech firm
News FinWise, which provides loans on behalf of US financial services firms, revealed a former employee accessed sensitive customer information after leaving the firm.
By Ross Kelly Published
-
UK to host largest European GPU cluster under £11 billion Nvidia investment plans
News Nvidia says the UK will host Europe’s largest GPU cluster, totaling 120,000 Blackwell GPUs by the end of 2026, in a major boost for the country’s sovereign compute capacity.
By Rory Bathgate Published
-
This DeepSeek-powered pen testing tool could be a Cobalt Strike successor – and hackers have downloaded it 10,000 times since July
News ‘Villager’, a tool developed by a China-based red team project known as Cyberspike, is being used to automate attacks under the guise of penetration testing.
By Rory Bathgate Published