Have ISPs finally lost the DEA fight?
BT and TalkTalk have been defeated in their latest challenge to the Digital Economy Act. Have the final obstacles now been cleared? Simon Brew investigates.
Since it was rushed through the legislative process, both before and after the general election of 2010, the Digital Economy Act (DEA) has been a contentious piece of work.
ISPs, with some justification, didn't take kindly to this plan.
The result of an initial report by Lord Carter Of Barnes, it headed to the statute book with concerns about just how deeply it had been interrogated. It was introduced by the Labour government just before the close of Parliament, and picked up by the subsequent coalition administration, none of whom threw any particular sticks in its wheels.
Alarm
From the off, many businesses and professionals, Internet Service Providers (ISPs) very much included, were sounding alarm bells. In particular, the proposed three strikes rule for broadband customers has remained a major point of contention. For amongst its many clauses in the Act is one demanding that ISPs send warning letters to people suspected of illegally downloading copyrighted material, and in extreme cases, terminating their connection.
ISPs, with some justification, didn't take kindly to this plan (which gives them a policing role of sorts), and many have been strongly resisting it ever since. BT and TalkTalk, in particular, have been following due legal process in their battle against parts of the Digital Economy Act, arguing that asking them to effectively police their customers by sending them letters and threats was in contravention of European Union law.
Earlier this month, this case finally made it to the Court Of Appeal. Unfortunately for BT and TalkTalk, their appeal was dismissed, and that's certainly cleared the path a little more to the implementation of the act.
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2026 report - the leading resource for IT decision-maker insight on priorities and investment areas in AI, security and more.
-
TfL takes Oyster photocard systems offline following breachNews Security experts warn the Oyster photocard breach could lead to follow-up attacks on victims
-
Irish credit unions hit by data breach after IT provider compromisedNews Wellington IT reportedly delayed alerting customers by multiple weeks
-
Startup founders lament 'regulatory friction' despite EU simplification effortsNews Entrepreneurs are spending a fortune on compliance, and it’s forcing some to consider relocating
-
Three things you need to know about the EU Data Act ahead of this week's big compliance deadlineNews A host of key provisions in the EU Data Act will come into effect on 12 September, and there’s a lot for businesses to unpack.
-
Cyber pros say the buck stops with the board when it comes to security failingsNews Fines, sanctions, and even prosecution are all on the table when it comes to cyber failings, practitioners believe
-
UK financial services firms are scrambling to comply with DORA regulationsNews Lack of prioritization and tight implementation schedules mean many aren’t compliant
-
Equinix acquires BT's Irish data centers in €59 million dealNews As BT moves to an asset-light business model, Equinix looks to expand
-
Does your security strategy show continuous improvement?Sponsored Content It’s important to do a regular check-up on your security systems and look at how you can implement continuous improvement as part of your security strategy
-
Protecting your cloud from malicious actorsSPONSORED In today’s multi-cloud world, there are more attack surfaces than ever for hackers to target - here’s what you can do to protect your business
-
The threats targeting operational technology and how to beat themSPONSORED Attackers looking to exploit overlooked flaws in OT or infect networks laterally can only be stopped with comprehensive observability strategies