US Supreme Court rejects telco antitrust lawsuit

Court sets high standard for conspiracy theorists; individual's attempt at starting class-action against local carriers fails

The nationwide telephone system in the US was broken up nearly 25 years ago, but that has not impeded customers from crying foul over perceived monopolistic behavior. Now that the former Bell operating companies are coagulating at an accelerated rate (AT&T, Verizon, and Qwest control virtually all of the local lines in the country) and the entire US telephone landscape is virtually dominated by three former Bell System companies, the pushback is likely to continue-but it will have to meet a strict legal standard in order to succeed, if today's US Supreme Court ruling is any indication.

William Twombly, a private individual, filed a lawsuit four years ago against the major carriers and their forerunners, charging them with monopolistic behavior and conspiracy. Chief among his arguments was the fact that despite a large-scale lifting of restrictions in 1996 which had previously kept local phone companies penned into their own territories by law, virtually no attempts were made by the major carriers to cross into new markets with local phone and broadband services, even though many startup and regional carriers availed themselves of the opportunity.

In the majority ruling, the court rejected the conclusion of an earlier appeals court, saying Twombly had not sufficiently established the basis of a true conspiracy to behave monopolistically. The court decision appeared to agree with quoted statements from telco executives, saying that the costs and regulatory uncertainty outweighed the potential benefits, and that lacking stronger evidence a trial could not proceed.

Featured Resources

BCDR buyer's guide for MSPs

How to choose a business continuity and disaster recovery solution

Download now

The definitive guide to IT security

Protecting your MSP and your customers

Download now

Cost of a data breach report 2020

Find out what factors help mitigate breach costs

Download now

The complete guide to changing your phone system provider

Optimise your phone system for better business results

Download now

Most Popular

KPMG offers staff 'four-day fortnight' in hybrid work plans
flexible working

KPMG offers staff 'four-day fortnight' in hybrid work plans

6 May 2021
Dell patches vulnerability affecting hundreds of computer models worldwide
cyber security

Dell patches vulnerability affecting hundreds of computer models worldwide

5 May 2021
16 ways to speed up your laptop
Laptops

16 ways to speed up your laptop

29 Apr 2021