IT Pro is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Arizona legislators vote against exclusive app store payment systems

HB2005 would stop Apple from forcing its payment system on developers and users

The Arizona House of Representatives has passed a bill that would throttle Apple's ability to enforce its app store payment policies.

The legislation (HB2005) passed in a 31-29 vote in the Republican-controlled House as an amendment to Title 18 of the Arizona revised statutes. The amendment, which adds a seventh chapter to that section, is just three pages but significant for companies running app stores, like Apple or Google.

The law targets app store providers offering more than a million downloads and prevents them from requiring an Arizona-based developer to use an exclusive in-app payment system. The app store providers also can’t force Arizona-based users to use an exclusive payment system. The law also makes it illegal to retaliate against a developer or user based in the state for using an alternative payment system.

The document applies to "general purpose hardware," including tablets, smartphones, and PCs of any kind, which also brings Macs under its scope. The language of the clause seems to call this out, specifically including in its scope "A digital distribution platform that is provided or used for only certain types of devices, such as certain grades of computing device, devices that are made by only a particular manufacturer or devices that run a particular operating system.”

The case comes at a thorny time for Apple and Google, as game publisher Epic sued them last August over commission collection via their in-app payment systems. While Google has tried to distance its dispute with Epic from Apple's, citing its policy of permitting multiple app stores on its smartphones, Epic's battle with Apple is especially bitter.

Apple takes a 30% commission on sales through its app store. Last year, Epic promised a 20% discount for customers who bought its in-game currency directly rather than buying through Apple's ecosystem. Epic sued Apple after the smartphone manufacturer responded by removing its game from the app store.

Since then, other companies, including Spotify, ProtonMail, Basecamp, and Tinder owner Match Group, have formed an alliance called the Coalition for App Fairness that’s protesting Apple's terms and conditions. Epic has also filed an antitrust complaint against Apple in Europe.

The Coalition welcomed the move yesterday. "The Coalition for App Fairness is pleased to see the House passage of #HB2005, which will encourage business innovation in Arizona and protect consumer choice," it tweeted. "While this is cause for celebration, it is only a first step toward achieving a truly level playing field for all."

This is not the only state-level legislative action addressing terms and conditions in digital markets. In February, a similar bill in North Dakota failed to pass, and Minnesota announced a similar bill last month. 

The issue has also prompted scrutiny from government regulators. Today, the UK Competition and Markets Authority announced an investigation into Apple over suspected anti-competitive behavior.

HB2005 now goes to the state Senate for another vote.

Featured Resources

Meeting the future of education with confidence

How the switch to digital learning has created an opportunity to meet the needs of every student, always

Free Download

The Total Economic Impact™ of IBM Cloud Pak® for Watson AIOps with Instana

Cost savings and business benefits

Free Download

The business value of the transformative mainframe

Modernising on the mainframe

Free Download

Technology reimagined

Why PCaaS is perfect for modern schools

Free Download

Recommended

Best business smartphones 2022: The top handsets from Apple, Samsung, Google and more
Mobile

Best business smartphones 2022: The top handsets from Apple, Samsung, Google and more

23 Jun 2022
Apple faces a catch-22 decision with iPhones and USB-C
Policy & legislation

Apple faces a catch-22 decision with iPhones and USB-C

8 Jun 2022
Apple overhauls SwiftUI navigation and brings a score of new features to developers at WWDC 2022
software development

Apple overhauls SwiftUI navigation and brings a score of new features to developers at WWDC 2022

7 Jun 2022
The EU’s Apple App Store crackdown ‘will fuel cyber attacks’
cyber security

The EU’s Apple App Store crackdown ‘will fuel cyber attacks’

1 Jun 2022

Most Popular

How to boot Windows 11 in Safe Mode
Microsoft Windows

How to boot Windows 11 in Safe Mode

7 Jun 2022
Delivery firm Yodel disrupted by cyber attack
cyber attacks

Delivery firm Yodel disrupted by cyber attack

21 Jun 2022
Salaries for the least popular programming languages surge as much as 44%
Development

Salaries for the least popular programming languages surge as much as 44%

23 Jun 2022