Enterprises need to stop shoehorning AI where it isn’t needed
Successful AI deployments require clear use cases and “upfront preparation”
Enterprises are struggling to deliver improvements to IT infrastructure with AI, according to new research from Gartner, with IT leaders facing serious integration challenges.
In a recent survey of infrastructure and operations (I&O) leaders, the consultancy found only 28% of AI use-cases “fully succeed and meet ROI expectations”. Around 20% fail outright, meanwhile.
A key factor in failure rates is that enterprises are essentially shoehorning AI into areas that aren’t applicable and expecting immediate returns.
Melanie Freeze, director of research at Gartner, said many AI initiatives are either “overly ambitious or poorly scoped”.
More than half (57%) of respondents have reported at least one failure in this regard, Gartner found, and Freeze noted that many “expected too much, too fast”.
“They assumed AI would immediately automate complex tasks, cut costs, or fix long-standing operational issues,” she wrote in a recent blog post.
“When expectations are not realistically set and the results don’t appear quickly, confidence drops and projects stall.”
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2026 report - the leading resource for IT decision-maker insight on priorities and investment areas in AI, security and more.
Other factors, such as internal skills capabilities, also play a key role in success or failure with AI projects. More than one-third (38%) of I&O leaders said “persistent skills gaps” have had a serious negative impact on projects.
A similar number of respondents also identified poor data quality or data availability as a contributing factor behind a failed AI project.
Separating the winners from the losers
Gartner’s survey found that successful AI deployment rarely depends on the sophistication or quality of the technology, but instead rests on how well it is integrated, governed, and “aligned with real operational needs”.
Simply put, a clear-cut strategy and relevant use cases are vital to ensuring successful delivery. Freeze noted that I&O leaders that have reported success “don’t run AI as side projects” and “start with realistic business cases and upfront preparation”.
Around one-third (33%) of successful I&O leaders have embedded AI within systems and processes that staff already use in their daily workflows, allowing for a more seamless integration process.
Freeze added that a large portion of successful deployments came in IT service management (ISTM) and cloud operations, two areas where markets are “mature” and boast “proven business value”.
More than half (53%) of I&O leaders reported that successful initiatives have occurred in ITSM, Gartner found.
The study also highlighted a “strong correlation between success and leadership buy-in”.
More than one-quarter (26%) of leaders who’ve reported success said they had full executive support, while 25% said they relied heavily on cross-functional collaboration to implement the technology.
“This matters because executive backing helps remove roadblocks, align priorities, and ensure the investment stays funded and focused,” according to Freeze.
FOLLOW US ON SOCIAL MEDIA
Follow ITPro on Google News and add us as a preferred source to keep tabs on all our latest news, analysis, views, and reviews.
You can also follow ITPro on LinkedIn, X, Facebook, and BlueSky.
Ross Kelly is ITPro's News & Analysis Editor, responsible for leading the brand's news output and in-depth reporting on the latest stories from across the business technology landscape. Ross was previously a Staff Writer, during which time he developed a keen interest in cyber security, business leadership, and emerging technologies.
He graduated from Edinburgh Napier University in 2016 with a BA (Hons) in Journalism, and joined ITPro in 2022 after four years working in technology conference research.
For news pitches, you can contact Ross at ross.kelly@futurenet.com, or on Twitter and LinkedIn.
-
Know your Microsoft 365 data, trust your recoveryHow contextual intelligence helps IT teams reduce ROT, protect sensitive content, and govern AI access
-
Five ways CISOs can use ‘dark AI’ to their own advantageIn-Depth Vulnerability discovery will explode over the next few years, but CIOs can use AI to beat hackers at their own game
-
Gartner says CIOs must apply the brakes on AI to balance value and riskNews Careless AI consumption is having the biggest drag on AI momentum, according to Gartner analysts
-
‘This is a massive change’: PagerDuty wants to supercharge incident response with a new SRE agent and command centerNews The new Paige agent from PagerDuty will act as a digital assistant for teams battling incidents
-
‘Organizations will not generate cost savings from AI at this point’: Just 3% of companies have recorded cost savings with AI – but that isn’t stopping them from investing moreNews More than one-third of AI projects have run over budget, but business leaders are still bullish on investment
-
A big tech taskforce has unveiled a blueprint for UK AI leadership – but time for action is running outNews Success depends on deeper collaboration between government, industry, local leaders and communities
-
Microsoft says AI is causing a workforce rupture among British businesses – leaders are backing the technology, but workers still aren’t soldNews New Microsoft research shows a huge disconnect between leadership and employees when it comes to confidence in the UK leading in AI
-
ISACA CEO says AI compliance will be like 'SOX on steroids'News Businesses will need to do far more work in far less time to meet stringent regulations
-
‘The most useful thing a leader can do right now is admit the plan is unfinished’: Workers are being told to use AI, but not why to use it – here’s why that mattersNews A Culture Amp survey shows workers are eager for AI tools, but they'd like to know the business goal of the technology
-
AI skills investment could boost the UK economy by £80 billion – but there's still a long way to go before firms can capitalize on the technologyNews Researchers are calling for a Skills Tax Credit to incentivize employers