RSA 2016: Weakened encryption compromises national security
Terrorists will move to other platforms, while criminals will exploit the flaws, claim speakers
Tech leaders have hit out at government snooping and attempts to break encryption on the first day of RSA Conference 2016.
On the same day that Apple once again came face-to-face with the FBI in a court hearing in LA, down the coast in San Francisco, Amit Yoran, president of RSA, used his opening keynote to criticise governments for allowing intelligence and law enforcement agencies to dominate the security conversation.
"We need governments to enact policies that help, rather than hinder security, providing opportunities for talent development," he told delegates.
Yoran said that the aims and perspectives of such agencies are "radically different" to those of people trying to defend networks, and said policy proposals such as weakening encryption "boggle the mind".
"In an era when cybersecurity is consistently cited as the single greatest threat to our way of life - above terrorism and all else - how can we possible justify a policy that would catastrophically weaken our infrastructures?" asked Yoran.
"Weakening encryption is solely for the ease and convenience of law enforcement when they are pursuing petty criminals. No credible terrorist or nation state actor would ever use technology that is knowingly weakened. However, if you weaken our encryption you can sure bet that the bad guys will use that and exploit it against us," he added.
These thoughts were echoed by Brad Smith, general legal counsel at Microsoft, who took to the stage after Yoran for his own keynote.
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2026 report - the leading resource for IT decision-maker insight on priorities and investment areas in AI, security and more.
Smith reflected on not just the big hacks of the past few years but also the terrorist attacks that hit Paris and San Bernardino in late 2015.
"People went to work [the day after these attacks] debating whether this meant new steps needed to be taken for technology, for surveillance, for encryption," said Smith. "We live in a world where every week there is a pendulum and the question is, which way will the pendulum swing on these issues that affect us?"
Smith argued that it was impossible to ensure people's security in real life if their security cannot be ensured online.
"The internet started out two decades ago as something people talked about as a different space - cyberspace, as if it were disconnected from real space and the real world. Well, what we've learnt today is that if people want to shape and impact what happens in the real world, they go to the internet," said Smith.
"This has affected everybody - governments around the world studied the Sony case and they realised that there is no such thing as national security in this decade without cyber security. We've realised that hence we need to keep information secure. One thing is clear above all else - people will not use technology they do not trust and hence trust is the absolute foundation for our entire industry and it needs to remain that way," Smith concluded.
Smith and Yoran's comments also come on the same day Theresa May introduced a new draft of the Investigatory Powers Bill to Parliament. The new text still contains a controversial provision that would oblige companies, including RSA, Microsoft and Apple, to remove encryption at the request of law enforcement agencies.
Jane McCallion is Managing Editor of ITPro and ChannelPro, specializing in data centers, enterprise IT infrastructure, and cybersecurity. Before becoming Managing Editor, she held the role of Deputy Editor and, prior to that, Features Editor, managing a pool of freelance and internal writers, while continuing to specialize in enterprise IT infrastructure, and business strategy.
Prior to joining ITPro, Jane was a freelance business journalist writing as both Jane McCallion and Jane Bordenave for titles such as European CEO, World Finance, and Business Excellence Magazine.
-
TfL takes Oyster photocard systems offline following breachNews Security experts warn the Oyster photocard breach could lead to follow-up attacks on victims
-
Irish credit unions hit by data breach after IT provider compromisedNews Wellington IT reportedly delayed alerting customers by multiple weeks
-
"Consumer messaging apps were never designed to handle sensitive communications" – Government decision-makers are confused about messaging security, BlackBerry report findsNews Despite official warnings, they're still routinely using WhatsApp for confidential communications
-
The key risks security teams face in 2026From AI-related flaws to supply chain risks, cyber professionals now contend with overlapping challenges
-
UK government to fund regional tech programs up to £20mnews Local and regional partnerships invited to bid for support for established or developing projects
-
RSAC in focus: Key takeaways for CISOsThe RSAC Conference 2025 spotlighted pivotal advancements in agentic AI, identity security, and collaborative defense strategies, shaping the evolving mandate for CISOs.
-
RSAC in focus: Quantum computing and securityExperts at RSAC 2025 emphasize the need for urgent action to secure data against future cryptographic risks posed by quantum computing
-
RSAC in focus: How AI is improving cybersecurityAI is revolutionizing cybersecurity by enhancing threat detection, automating defenses, and letting IT professionals tackle evolving digital challenges.
-
RSAC in focus: Collaboration in cybersecurityExperts at RSA Conference 2025 emphasised that collaboration across sectors and shared intelligence are pivotal to addressing the evolving challenges of cybersecurity.
-
RSAC in focus: Considerations and possibilities for the remainder of 2025As 2025 unfolds, RSAC explores the pivotal considerations and emerging possibilities shaping the cybersecurity landscape