In search of the Linux desktop
How can GNOME and KDE developers create the modern Linux desktop?
At the extreme end of the phenomenon, developers are accused of self indulgence, forcing change on unwilling users, and worse.
Users are an essential part of the Free Software development process. As Alan Cox once put it: "I find it sad that many people when asked to name the most important five Linux kernel people rarely name some of the most important folk of all - those who maintain websites, change logs, mailing lists and documentation... When you hear 'I'd love to help but I can't program', you hear a documenter. When they say 'But English is not my first language' you have a documenter and a translator for another language'."
Users who cannot program can contribute in other ways, add to the discussion and change the way that things are done. The willingness of users to document and translate the software, to maintain the development trees and mailing lists, to report bugs and give feedback to the developers, has been a vital element in the spread of Free Software.
The users who complain that change is being "forced" on them are misunderstanding how free software works. Anybody can get involved, join the discussions, and more importantly, contribute to what comes out of them.
The open source imperative
The KDE developers ran into problems with KDE 4.0 because, of necessity, changes to the applications lagged behind changes to the framework. As the new environment has matured and the relationship between the applications and the desktop environment has become more transparent, attitudes have begun to change.
Acceptance of the new KDE requires a subtle shift in perceptions and understanding before long time users can recover their work flow. Perhaps not everything works as well as it might, some applications, notably Amorak, are still not back to what they were, and some aspects of Plasma and the widgets framework will change over time.
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2026 report - the leading resource for IT decision-maker insight on priorities and investment areas in AI, security and more.
Now that the GNOME developers are suggesting change on a similar scale the proposals have met with similar reactions. One set of users hopes for the great leap forward. Another set of users worries that GNOME will lose the traditional virtues of simplicity and transparency.
As the experience of Linus Torvalds illustrates, there are no easy rules that fit every user, and usability as it is applied to the desktop means little more than a set of compromises, which cannot satisfy every demand.
-
Why is Windows 11 so disliked by programmers – and can Microsoft do anything to change things?In-depth Windows isn't the most useful OS in the eyes of developers, with programmers preferring macOS or Linux. But is its bad reputation uncalled for?
-
AI is coming to Ubuntu: Canonical exec teases future AI features and agentic workflow capabilities for version 26.10 — but on a ‘strictly opt-in basis’News A range of new AI features are coming to Ubuntu over the next year, according to maintainers, but only providing they’re of “sufficient maturity and quality”.
-
Windows 10 extended support costs could top $7 billionNews Enterprises sticking with Windows 10 after the October deadline face huge costs
-
Tiny11 review: Windows 11 with only 2GB of RAMReview A version of Windows 11 for older machines that don't meet the full requirements
-
Red Hat Enterprise Linux becomes foundational operating system for Cohesity Data CloudNews New strategic partnership between Red Hat and Cohesity aims to drive innovation in the data security and management space
-
Ubuntu shifts to four-week update cycleNews Critical fixes will also come every two weeks, mitigating the issues involved with releasing prompt patches on the old three-week cadence
-
AlmaLinux follows Oracle in ditching RHEL compatibilityNews Application binary compatibility is now the aim with 1:1 now dropped
-
How big is the Windows 10 cliff-edge?ITPro Network With some comparing the upcoming Windows 10 end of life to Windows XP, we ask members of the ITPro Network for their insight