Mobiles on the tube: Move down the carriage or stand clear?
With a deal to get mobile connectivity on the tube coming closer and closer, we ask whether a good service on all London Underground lines is what commuters really want.


So Owen might be for it and the public might be against it, but what are the real benefits for businesses if we get this increased access on our way to work?
Rob Bamforth, principal analyst at Quocirca, claimed there could be some real positives for the commuter.
"[With] data the ability to do email, get news or find out about timings and platforms of connecting trains etc might be really useful," he told IT PRO.
"In many respects that might offload the network overcrowding impact at locations, such as mainline stations, as commuters might have already done what they needed to do en route."
Bamforth also thought many would enjoy being able to use their mobiles either for "distraction or business" but rules would need to be put in place to keep everyone happy.
"Given the noise, packed carriages etc voice calls would be a bit of a pain for both those making and those surrounding them," he added.
"If they need to shout to be heard, that's a recipe for arguments and we'd need to see more quiet zones' or something similar."
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
Mile End of the road
Despite all the noise about mobile underground this week, there is still a long way to go until we hit this final destination.
On Monday, Johnson spoke at Finsbury Park Station to highlight the fall in crime on the capital's public transport network but could not avoid the questions around mobile coverage.
He said it was both "commercially" and "technically difficult" and urged caution about getting too far ahead of ourselves.
Admitting a lot of people wouldn't be pro the idea, Johnson said: "We have been unable to do it because our tunnels are so narrow, but in the long run it is progress. I think it is the way to go and we have got to give people the ability to text and perhaps have some coverage for voice telephony."
He added: "The issue is not so much the Chinese company that is offering to help or security issues. The issue is the technology given we have got very old and narrow tunnels. I am not ruling it out but I am not ruling it in either.
"It is on the way but do not count your chickens."
Jennifer Scott is a former freelance journalist and currently political reporter for Sky News. She has a varied writing history, having started her career at Dennis Publishing, working in various roles across its business technology titles, including ITPro. Jennifer has specialised in a number of areas over the years and has produced a wealth of content for ITPro, focusing largely on data storage, networking, cloud computing, and telecommunications.
Most recently Jennifer has turned her skills to the political sphere and broadcast journalism, where she has worked for the BBC as a political reporter, before moving to Sky News.
-
This live map of every London Underground tube train will make you appreciate open data
News The mesmerising project wouldn’t be possible without TfL’s open API
By Adam Shepherd
-
Uber's top UK exec quits
News Jo Bertram leaves for new role, but says "current challenges" mean a change of face is necessary
By Nicole Kobie
-
TfL passes 1 billion contactless journeys
News Almost half of pay as you go users are opting to pay via contactless technology
By Clare Hopping
-
TfL hopes to ease traffic with crowdsourced data
News The organisation has teamed up with Waze to offer real-time information about traffic congestion
By Clare Hopping
-
TfL implements e-paper bus stop signage
News The signs will show real-time scheduling of buses rather than the digital info seen on some stops
By Clare Hopping
-
TfL pays Atos £6m as part of move to a SIAM model
News Transport body impressed with outsourcer’s experience in handling service desk operations
By Joe Curtis
-
Amazon teams up with Post Office for online deliveries
News Argos also bringing click and collect to underground stations
By Rene Millman
-
TfL brings contactless payments to London's tube network
News Following trials on buses, you can now use your contactless payment cards on London Underground and Overground lines
By Clare Hopping