Google and privacy: What’s the problem?
Google’s unification of its privacy policies has brought the firm wide criticism. But what’s actually the issue? Simon Brew has been taking a look…

Trouble
Well, plenty. Perhaps, most importantly, there's the suggestion that Google is actually in breach of the law. The EU has argued that Google's new policy is unlawful, and American legislators are also believed to be raising concerns. The EU is arguing that Google is in breach of its directive regarding data protection, and discussions are believed to be ongoing.
Google, for its part, resisted calls to suspend the roll-out of its policy changes, and implemented them on 1 March 2012, arguing that it had consulted beforehand. Expect the legal arguments to go on for some time yet, then.
But again, what's actually the problem? For changes that are supposed to be so consumer friendly, why is there so much consternation about them?
Double trouble
There are two problems. Firstly, there's the manner in which Google has gone about the changes. Appreciating it's in something of a damned if you do, damned if you don't position, the issue here is that such major changes, no matter how friendly they're presented, have been rushed through, bypassing seemingly essential scrutiny as they've been accelerated.
Furthermore, there's been no real open central method by which users can ask questions and query just what's going on.
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
Google was never going to win itself many friends by altering a privacy policy in the first place, as it's hardly the kind of thing that large companies like to draw attention to. Its almost stealth-like approach to the change has aroused, at the very least, a lot of suspicion.
-
Capita tells pension provider to 'assume' nearly 500,000 customers' data stolen
Capita told the pension provider to “work on the assumption” that data had been stolen
By Ross Kelly
-
Gumtree site code made personal data of users and sellers publicly accessible
News Anyone could scan the website's HTML code to reveal personal information belonging to users of the popular second-hand classified adverts website
By Connor Jones
-
Pizza chain exposed 100,000 employees' Social Security numbers
News Former and current staff at California Pizza Kitchen potentially burned by hackers
By Danny Bradbury
-
83% of critical infrastructure companies have experienced breaches in the last three years
News Survey finds security practices are weak if not non-existent in critical firms
By Rene Millman
-
Identity Automation launches credential breach monitoring service
News New monitoring solution adds to the firm’s flagship RapidIdentity platform
By Praharsha Anand
-
Neiman Marcus data breach hits 4.6 million customers
News The breach took place last year, but details have only now come to light
By Rene Millman
-
Indiana notifies 750,000 after COVID-19 tracing data accessed
News The state is following up to ensure no information was transferred to bad actors
By Rene Millman
-
Pearson fined $1 million for downplaying severity of 2018 breach
News The SEC found the London-based firm made “misleading statements and omissions” about the intrusion
By Rene Millman