Lawyers for popular file-sharing company Megaupload, accused of copyright theft and internet piracy, have moved to have the case thrown out, a US counsel said on Thursday.
Before it was shut down in January, Megaupload was one of the world's most popular websites, where millions of users stored data, either for free or by paying for premium service.
The law states that you can't indict and serve a company that does not have a presence in the United States
The FBI claims founder Kim Dotcom masterminded a scheme that made more than $175 million in a few short years by copying and distributing music, movies and other copyrighted content without authorisation.
Papers have been filed stating that US federal authorities cannot charge the company with criminal behavior because it is Hong Kong based, and also that no papers have ever been formally served, the lawyer said.
Megaupload's assets were seized and its executives in New Zealand and Holland arrested in January on warrants issued by the FBI alleging money laundering, internet piracy, and illegal file sharing.
But Megaupload's US counsel said the FBI had made a fundamental mistake.
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2026 report - the leading resource for IT decision-maker insight on priorities and investment areas in AI, security and more.
"The law here in the United States is that you can't indict and then serve a company that does not have a presence in the United States," Ira Rothken told Radio New Zealand.
He said the case against Megaupload and its executives should be dismissed.
"This case was flawed from the start, once this case gets dismissed it cannot be fixed," Rothken said.
Megaupload chief executive Dotcom, 39, spent nearly a month in jail after New Zealand police raided a luxury country estate and cut him out of a safe room in which he had barricaded himself.
US authorities have asked for him and three other executives to be extradited.
Megaupload has always maintained that it simply offered online storage, and that music and movie companies were given every opportunity to have illegal material removed.
Dotcom is on bail after he convinced a court that he was not going to abscond.
In the past week he has been allowed back to his mansion, and had travel restrictions eased. A New Zealand judge also ordered prosecutors to give Dotcom's lawyers access to evidence collected against him and co-defendants.
Rothken said he had also filed papers in the U.S. to unfreeze Megaupload funds, which could be used by the defendants to defend themselves.
The FBI was not immediately available for comment.
ITPro is a global business technology website providing the latest news, analysis, and business insight for IT decision-makers. Whether it's cyber security, cloud computing, IT infrastructure, or business strategy, we aim to equip leaders with the data they need to make informed IT investments.
For regular updates delivered to your inbox and social feeds, be sure to sign up to our daily newsletter and follow on us LinkedIn and Twitter.
-
TfL takes Oyster photocard systems offline following breachNews Security experts warn the Oyster photocard breach could lead to follow-up attacks on victims
-
Irish credit unions hit by data breach after IT provider compromisedNews Wellington IT reportedly delayed alerting customers by multiple weeks
-
Liberty defeated in ‘snooper’s charter’ legal challengeNews High court rules the government’s Investigatory Powers Act doesn’t breach human rights
-
GCHQ’s mass data collection practices breached human rights law, European court rulesNews Surveillance methods disclosed by Edward Snowden in 2013 ruled illegal in landmark ruling
-
Coalition Against Piracy fights online piracyNews The new coalition, backed by numerous companies, hopes to dismantle the businesses behind pirate streaming boxes
-
Google and Microsoft agree to crack down on piracyNews Tech firms sign up to voluntary code of conduct
-
Linking to Playboy piracy isn't infringement, says EU advisorNews Advocate general delivery advisory ahead of landmark case
-
Swedish ISPs cannot be forced to block The Pirate BayNews Swedish court rules that ISPs cannot be legally compelled to block file-sharing sites on the grounds of copyright infringement
-
Online pirates could face same prison term as sex offendersIn-depth Harsher penalties for online piracy are 'not appropriate', warns paralegal
-
Why ISPs are blocking ebook piracy sitesNews Publishers Association wins piracy site ban after millions of takedown requests