IT Pro is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

WannaCry-style cyber attack could trigger full NATO response, says Secretary General

It marks the second time the military alliance has tried to incorporate cyber threats into the treaty

A shot of the NATO headquarters surrounded by European flags

NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg has said a cyber attack on a single member state could constitute an attack on all 29 members.

The announcement effectively incorporates cyber security into Article 5 of the NATO founding treaty, a "collective defence commitment" which compels all members to come to the defence of one or more countries threatened by external powers.

"We have designated cyberspace a domain in which NATO will operate and defend itself as effectively as it does in the air, on land, and at sea," Stoltenberg said, in an article featured in Prospect Magazine. "This means we will deter and defend against any aggression towards allies, whether it takes place in the physical world or the virtual one."

"The more information we have, the more prepared we are," he added. "By working with the European Union, strengthening the ways in which we share information, train, educate, and conduct exercises together, we will ensure that we have the most robust tools possible for responding to the growing cyberthreat."

Stoltenberg cited the WannaCry attack in 2017, which affected NHS hospitals and public sector bodies across the UK, as an example of a major cyber attack that would prompt coordinated action from NATO members.

This is the second time NATO has said it would incorporate cyber security into the treaty, having first announced plans back in 2014. However, little has been done to date to formalise the motion, and Article 5 was not triggered during the WannaCry incident.

The proposed change would largely formalise a response model based on existing examples of countries cooperating to fight cyber attacks. Specifically, Stoltenberg mentions recent joint efforts by the Netherlands and the UK in October 2018 to foil an attack by Russia on the Hague's chemical weapons research group.

NATO also operates its own Cyber Coalition, a programme that features some of the largest cyber defence exercises in the world.

Article 5 of the NATO treaty has not been triggered since the 9/11 terrorist attacks against US targets in 2001.

Complicated nature of cyber warfare

Although it makes sense to bring Nato's defence capabilities in line with modern threats, the murky world of cyber warfare will almost certainly create problems for the organisation.

As a military alliance, NATO exists to protect its members from the actions of aggressive states or paramilitary groups, protections that now include cyber. However, if cyber warfare in the 21st century has taught us anything, it's that it's almost impossible to attribute blame. Most attacks are coordinated by anonymous hacking groups and only rarely do we get information that could potentially tie one group to a state's government.

What's also unclear is how NATO will define a major cyber attack in the future, and how big it needs to be to merit a coordinated response. The WannaCry attack cited was perhaps one of the most disruptive cases of ransomware we have seen to date, affecting over 200,000 computer systems worldwide yet comparatively speaking we have seen few attacks of that scale since. If that is indeed the threshold, Article 5 may only be triggered in very rare circumstances.

Featured Resources

2023 Strategic roadmap for data security platform convergence

Capitalise on your data and share it securely using consolidated platforms

Free Download

The 3D trends report

Presenting one of the most exciting frontiers in visual culture

Free Download

The Total Economic Impact™ of IBM Cloud Pak® for Watson AIOps with Instana

Cost savings and business benefits

Free Download

Leverage automated APM to accelerate CI/CD and boost application performance

Constant change to meet fast-evolving application functionality

Free Download

Recommended

Ransomware now strikes one in 40 organisations per week, Check Point finds
ransomware

Ransomware now strikes one in 40 organisations per week, Check Point finds

27 Jul 2022
What is cyber warfare?
Security

What is cyber warfare?

20 May 2022
Darktrace AI’s Antigena helps stop ransomware attack at Dordogne GHT
ransomware

Darktrace AI’s Antigena helps stop ransomware attack at Dordogne GHT

13 Apr 2022

Most Popular

Warning issued over ransomware attacks targeting VMware ESXi servers globally
cyber attacks

Warning issued over ransomware attacks targeting VMware ESXi servers globally

6 Feb 2023
ION Trading reportedly pays LockBit ransom demands
ransomware

ION Trading reportedly pays LockBit ransom demands

6 Feb 2023
BT Group extends Kyndryl deal to migrate legacy mainframe apps to the cloud
Business strategy

BT Group extends Kyndryl deal to migrate legacy mainframe apps to the cloud

31 Jan 2023