Insights 2019: Epicor CEO warns against the dangers of ‘over-automating'
Steve Murphy mocks Tesla’s Elon Musk for underestimating the importance of people on the factory floor


Companies should be careful not to succumb to the temptation of automating as many business processes as possible when undergoing any digital transformation projects.
Manufacturers in particular should run any artificial intelligence (AI) projects through a 'litmus test' that asks whether or not this would augment human employees' functions or cause volatility, according to Epicor's CEO Steve Murphy.
"Investment in plant products, equipment, automating, building software at the process level is done because of a shortage of skills, or because labour's too expensive," Murphy said in his keynote address at Epicor's annual Insights conference, hosted this year in Las Vegas.
But there is such a thing as 'over-automation', with innovation and technological advancements actually leading to disruption and volatility in markets.
One key example of this, Murphy outlined, was by way of Tesla's Fremont plant in California, which features an almost-entirely automated manufacturing process. But, as a result of this, the plant sustained a severe manufacturing shortage last year.
"The cougar robots that work the line; people don't even get within ten metres, in some cases, of the cars being built," he told delegates during his keynote. "That's a case where it was probably taken too far."
The way Tesla CEO Elon Musk verbalised this, Murphy continued, was "I underestimated the value of human beings", which is another way of saying "I over-automated the plant".
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
"My counsel to my peer group here is that technology, as far as how much you use and how much you embed into the process, should be embedded to the degree that you can be competitive but no more so. That's it," said Murphy.
"If you go beyond that, and you've got a feature or function or something you can't make use of, you've gone too far. And in many cases you build a degree of rigidity and complexity in the system that doesn't work in your favour."
One further example of how innovation has led to curious cases of market volatility include the highly shortened release cycles for smartphones.
Apple and rival Android manufacturers like Huawei and Samsung are able to issue several releases per year. This, in turn, leads to wild pricing patterns that have a knock-on effect on other markets; figuratively-speaking the cost of a handset on day one could be $2000, for example, and half that price on day two.
Murphy added that if AI and automation can't allow a user to be more effective in their existing roles, then businesses would have to ask themselves what the point in deploying this new technology is.

Keumars Afifi-Sabet is a writer and editor that specialises in public sector, cyber security, and cloud computing. He first joined ITPro as a staff writer in April 2018 and eventually became its Features Editor. Although a regular contributor to other tech sites in the past, these days you will find Keumars on LiveScience, where he runs its Technology section.
-
Cisco takes aim at AI security at RSAC with ServiceNow partnership
News The companies claim Cisco AI Defense and ServiceNow SecOps will help address new challenges raised by AI
By Jane McCallion
-
Why veterans can excel in data centers – and could help the IT sector address its skill shortages
In-depth Ex-military workers can bring software and hardware to civilian roles
By John Loeppky
-
Automate personalization with AWS
Whitepaper How marketers can automate, deliver, and analyze billions of personalized messages and offers per day
By ITPro
-
How a hyper-automation platform can drive value for your bank
Whitepaper Five ways automated processes can drive revenue and growth
By ITPro
-
How Crew Clothing went mobile to turn around a struggling business
Case Study Mobile sales tech unleashed a tide of change, buoying further growth across the UK coast-inspired casualwear chain
By Fleur Doidge
-
Appian wants to be the AI company for AI skeptics
Analysis The firm outlines its AI strategy at Appian World 2023 while using ChatGPT and Midjourney to create scripts and imagery for keynote presentations
By Rory Bathgate
-
The Total Economic Impact™ of SAP finance transformation services with TruQua
Whitepaper Business benefits and cost savings enabled by accelerating the SAP central finance transformation
By ITPro
-
Avoiding cloud migration pitfalls for SAP
Whitepaper Determining the best approach to SAP HANA
By ITPro
-
Workday hit with claims its AI hiring systems are discriminatory
News An African American plaintiff has alleged that Workday's systems prevented him from being hired on the basis of his race, age, and mental health
By Rory Bathgate
-
Automation: The key to optimised server management
Whitepaper Deliver modern digital end-user experiences, innovate with data, and more flexibly deliver IT services
By ITPro