Motorola slams Microsoft patent ‘tactics’
Microsoft is accused of reversing its position on FRAND patents just to suit its current litigation strategy.


Motorola has bitten back at Microsoft after the Windows maker yesterday filed a a complaint with the European Commission over alleged abuse of standard essential patents.
In a blog post, Microsoft said Motorola was charging far more than it should for licensing of FRAND (fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory) patents and also slammed Google for not playing fair.
In particular, Microsoft was concerned about how much Motorola was charging for the video standard H.264, but the latter subsequently issued a rebuttal accusing Microsoft of hypocrisy.
Microsoft has simply reversed its position on FRAND in order to suit its current litigation strategy.
"Microsoft's complaint and blog posting ... are simply tactics in the patent battle that Microsoft initiated with surprise infringement actions against Motorola Mobility in October 2010 accompanied by press statements making clear the actions were aimed at Android," a Motorola spokesperson said.
"And Microsoft's complaint with the International Trade Commission sought injunctive relief against Motorola Mobility based on Microsoft's own standards essential patents. With its recent actions, Microsoft has simply reversed its position on FRAND in order to suit its current litigation strategy."
Motorola said it was open to resolving the current licensing dispute with Microsoft "in a mutually beneficial manner."
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
The mobile maker said it offered Microsoft the same FRAND terms it offered other licensees, but Microsoft rejected Motorola's prposals, "preferring instead to use litigation as its strategy."
"Microsoft has touted the value of patent licensing for its own patents, but a fair resolution requires that Microsoft also recognise the value of the Motorola Mobility patents it is using," the spokesperson added.
Yesterday, Google also issued a somewhat pugnacious response to Microsoft's criticisms.
"We haven't seen Microsoft's complaint, but it's consistent with the way they use the regulatory process to attack competitors," a spokesperson said.
"It's particularly ironic, given their track record in this area and collaboration with patent trolls."
Legal wars over IP, in particular FRAND patents, are getting increasingly heated.
Late last year Apple claimed in a court filing that Samsung was facing an antitrust probe over a potential abuse of FRAND patents against the iPhone creator.
Samsung had reportedly attempted to assert 3G-related patents covered by FRAND licensing commitments.
Tom Brewster is currently an associate editor at Forbes and an award-winning journalist who covers cyber security, surveillance, and privacy. Starting his career at ITPro as a staff writer and working up to a senior staff writer role, Tom has been covering the tech industry for more than ten years and is considered one of the leading journalists in his specialism.
He is a proud alum of the University of Sheffield where he secured an undergraduate degree in English Literature before undertaking a certification from General Assembly in web development.
-
Blackouts in Spain and Portugal could be a cyber attack
Both countries are "paralyzed" by nationwide power outages
By Jane McCallion
-
Cisco takes aim at AI security at RSAC with ServiceNow partnership
News The companies claim Cisco AI Defense and ServiceNow SecOps will help address new challenges raised by AI
By Jane McCallion
-
Apple, Meta hit back at EU after landmark DMA fines
News The European Commission has issued its first penalties under the EU Digital Markets Act (DMA), fining Apple €500 million and Meta €200m.
By Nicole Kobie
-
‘Europe could do it, but it's chosen not to do it’: Eric Schmidt thinks EU regulation will stifle AI innovation – but Britain has a huge opportunity
News Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt believes EU AI regulation is hampering innovation in the region and placing enterprises at a disadvantage.
By Ross Kelly
-
The EU just shelved its AI liability directive
News The European Commission has scrapped plans to introduce the AI Liability Directive aimed at protecting consumers from harmful AI systems.
By Ross Kelly
-
A big enforcement deadline for the EU AI Act just passed – here's what you need to know
News The first set of compliance deadlines for the EU AI Act passed on the 2nd of February, and enterprises are urged to ramp up preparations for future deadlines.
By George Fitzmaurice
-
EU agrees amendments to Cyber Solidarity Act in bid to create ‘cyber shield’ for member states
News The EU’s Cyber Solidarity Act will provide new mechanisms for authorities to bolster union-wide security practices
By Emma Woollacott
-
The EU's 'long-arm' regulatory approach could create frosty US environment for European tech firms
Analysis US tech firms are throwing their toys out of the pram over the EU’s Digital Markets Act, but will this come back to bite European companies?
By Solomon Klappholz
-
EU AI Act risks collapse if consensus not reached, experts warn
Analysis Industry stakeholders have warned the EU AI Act could stifle innovation ahead of a crunch decision
By Ross Kelly
-
Three quarters of UK firms unprepared for NIS2 regulations, study finds
News Senior management can be held personally liable for non-compliance under NIS2 rules
By Ross Kelly