Does the government want to snoop on your data?
Does the government really want you to tell them everything? And what are its new communications-watching plans all about? Simon Brew finds out more…
Home Office minister James Brokenshire has been trying to downplay the row that has broken out, arguing that "it's not about some new super-database or spying on the contents of everybody's communications".
Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg backs that up, saying that "I am totally opposed to the idea of governments reading people's emails at will, or creating a new central government database."
He argues that "all we are doing is updating the rules which currently apply to mobile telephone calls to allow the police and security services to go after terrorists and serious criminals, and updating that to apply to technology like Skype which is increasingly being used by people who want to make those calls and send those mails".
It's a traditional defence of any move that's perceived as impinging on civil liberties, and there's clearly something to the argument.
Even hardened civil liberties campaigners seem in agreement on that. Where the area of debate lies is where to draw the line. Under the extension of existing powers being proposed, there's the feeling of a grab everything, ask questions later' approach. That is, every piece of possible electronics communication is being stored, on the off chance that it might be needed. Campaigners argue that's the wrong way round.
It's not helped by the list of who's able to request information about your web use and communications details. In theory, local councils, the NHS, the Independent Police Complains Commission, the Office of Communications, the Royal Mail, the Department For Business, Innovation & Skills, the Food Standards Agency and many more can apply for access. In fact, under the existing legislation, the BBC reports that 552,550 requests were made for communications data in 2010, although not all of these were granted.
Big Brother Watch is one of the many organisations that raised objections to the plans. It argues that it's an "unprecedented step", that will see Britain adopt the same kind of surveillance as China and Iran", arguing "these plans are an unprecedented attack on privacy online and it is far from clear that this will actually improve public safety, while adding significant costs to internet business".
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2026 report - the leading resource for IT decision-maker insight on priorities and investment areas in AI, security and more.
-
CIOs need to take back control of their IT roadmapIn-Depth IT leaders are facing difficult decisions about their ERP estates – but experts say taking an ‘AI last’ approach can avoid costly disruption
-
TfL takes Oyster photocard systems offline following breachNews Security experts warn the Oyster photocard breach could lead to follow-up attacks on victims
-
Startup founders lament 'regulatory friction' despite EU simplification effortsNews Entrepreneurs are spending a fortune on compliance, and it’s forcing some to consider relocating
-
"Consumer messaging apps were never designed to handle sensitive communications" – Government decision-makers are confused about messaging security, BlackBerry report findsNews Despite official warnings, they're still routinely using WhatsApp for confidential communications
-
CIOs wrestle with Europe's new digital sovereignty approachNews Digital sovereignty is front and center for CIOs as organizations target more robust controls
-
UK government to fund regional tech programs up to £20mnews Local and regional partnerships invited to bid for support for established or developing projects
-
Three things you need to know about the EU Data Act ahead of this week's big compliance deadlineNews A host of key provisions in the EU Data Act will come into effect on 12 September, and there’s a lot for businesses to unpack.
-
Cyber pros say the buck stops with the board when it comes to security failingsNews Fines, sanctions, and even prosecution are all on the table when it comes to cyber failings, practitioners believe
-
Government’s ‘Humphrey’ AI tool helps local authorities cut costsNews The Minute tool, part of the Humphrey AI assistant, is being trialled at 25 councils
-
Former GCHQ intern risked national security after taking home top secret dataNews A former GCHQ intern has pleaded guilty to transferring data from a top-secret computer onto his work phone.