Former Sun chief backs Google in feud with Oracle
Java APIs used in Android were considered open, claims Jonathan Schwartz.

Former Sun Microsystems CEO Jonathan Schwartz is the latest high-profile executive to testify in the Google-Oracle patent trial, and could have given the search giant's defence a major boost.
When questioned about the nature of the Java APIs by Google's defence lawyer, Schwartz revealed they were not considered to be proprietary by Sun.
We didn't like what Google was doing with Android, but we weren't going to stop it by complaining about it.
"These are open APIs, and we wanted to bring in more people...we wanted to build the biggest tent and invite as many people as possible," he told the court.
Google has also used a blog post written by Schwartz in a bid to show that it was not violating any patents when using Java in the Android platform.
"I just wanted to add my voice to the chorus of others from Sun in offering my heartfelt congratulations to Google on the announcement of their new Java/Linux phone platform, Android," he wrote in 2007.
However, Schwartz claimed there were a lot of things unsaid in the blog, and not everything was as straightforward as it seemed.
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
"We didn't like [what Google was doing with Android], but we weren't going to stop it by complaining," Schwartz told the court
"We saw a handset bypass our brand and licensing restrictions...we decided to grit our teeth and support it so anyone supporting it would see us as part of the value chain."
Former Google CEO, Eric Schmidt, has already taken the stand and claimed that no concerns were raised about Java when Android was launched.
"My understanding is that what we were doing was permissible because of the sum of my experiences and interactions I had," Schmidt told the jury.
The combination of the testimonies and the Schwartz blog post could be a blow to Oracle, which acquired Sun in 2010 and has pursued Google for patent infringement.
The trial, which kicked off on 16 April, is expected to last eight weeks.
-
M&S suspends online sales as 'cyber incident' continues
News Marks & Spencer (M&S) has informed customers that all online and app sales have been suspended as the high street retailer battles a ‘cyber incident’.
By Ross Kelly
-
Manners cost nothing, unless you’re using ChatGPT
Opinion Polite users are costing OpenAI millions of dollars each year – but Ps and Qs are a small dent in what ChatGPT could cost the planet
By Ross Kelly
-
Organizations shift away from Oracle Java as pricing changes bite
News A survey from Azul Systems finds that, along with cost, customers cite a preference for open source and the threat of a Java usage audit
By Emma Woollacott
-
Why Java 17 growth is ‘exploding’
News Java 17 is now the most popular LTS version, according to application data from New Relic, but what's driving this growth?
By Steve Ranger
-
SuiteWorld 2023: NetSuite's day-two announcements
Live Blog Keep up-to-date with all the day-two announcements from NetSuite SuiteWorld 2023
By Rory Bathgate
-
Can Oracle really be Linux's knight in shining armor?
Opinion The self-proclaimed champion of open source freedom would like you to forget about its history
By Richard Speed
-
Oracle’s Java subscription changes spark concerns over cost hikes for smaller businesses
News Smaller businesses could incur significant cost hikes as high as 1,400% with most new customers expected to pay at least double
By Ross Kelly
-
Oracle to launch 14 new cloud regions over the next year
News The company wants to support the demand for its customers as it looks to open at least two regions in each country it operates
By Zach Marzouk
-
Windows 11 has problems with Oracle VirtualBox
News Microsoft confirms compatibility issues as new operating system makes its debut
By Rene Millman
-
Oracle plans $1.2 billion campus in Nashville, Tennessee
News The company is building ‘new digital hubs’ to meet demand for its cloud products
By Mike Brassfield