Oracle vs Google judge seeks names of paid reporters and bloggers
Court voices concern over paid coverage of legal dispute
The copyright and patent battle between Google and Oracle in the US took a strange twist on Tuesday, after a judge ordered the companies to disclose the names of journalists, bloggers and other commentators on their payrolls.
U.S. District Judge William Alsup said he was concerned that Google and Oracle and/or their counsel may have retained or paid people who may have published comment on the case.
The order, several months after a jury found that Google did not infringe on Oracle's patents, hints at the possibility of a hidden world of for-pay press coverage and injects uncertainty into the widely-followed case.
I think the judge is in uncharted territory with this order
Alsup issued a one page order but did not go into full details of the court's concerns.
"The court is concerned that the parties and/or counsel herein may have retained or paid print or internet authors, journalists, commentators or bloggers who have and/or may publish comments on the issues in the case," Alsup wrote in Tuesday's order.
He said the information "would be of use on appeal" and could "make clear whether any treatise, article, commentary or analysis on the issues posed by this case are possibly influenced by financial relationships to the parties or counsel."
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2026 report - the leading resource for IT decision-maker insight on priorities and investment areas in AI, security and more.
The companies must submit the information by noon on 17 August.
Oracle sued Google in US federal court, claiming the search engine giant's Android mobile platform violated its patents and copyright to Java, seeking roughly $1 billion on its copyright claims.
But the jury ruled in Google's favour and the judge decided Oracle could not claim copyright protection on most of the Java material that Oracle took to trial.
Oracle has said it will appeal.
The trial, which featured testimony from high-profile technology executives including Oracle Chief Executive Larry Ellison and Google CEO Larry Page, attracted heavy media coverage from the mainstream press and technology-focused blogs.
One of the more well-known bloggers on intellectual property matters and on the Oracle vs Google case, Florian Mueller, revealed three days into the trial that Oracle had recently become a consulting client of his. People who followed the case said they weren't aware of any other similar examples.
An Oracle spokeswoman said in a statement that the company has "always disclosed all of its financial relationships in this matter, and it is time for Google do to the same. We read this order to also include indirect payments to entities who, in turn, made comments on behalf of Google."
the company has "always disclosed all of its financial relationships in this matter, and it is time for Google do to the same
Google said the company would comply with the order.
What impact the order could have on the case remains unclear, legal experts said.
"I haven't seen anything quite like this before. I think the judge is in uncharted territory with this order," said Eric Goldman, a professor of Internet law at Santa Clara University School of Law.
Goldman said two potential reasons for the order would be if there were evidence that the jury had been swayed by extensive press coverage of the case or if the jury had relied on evidence not properly labelled as unbiased, such as a for-pay news article offered as an exhibit in the trial.
Goldman, who blogged about the case, said that he might likely appear on the list, since his website features ads distributed by Google's online advertising network.
"The court has really wide discretion in granting a remedy to fix any kind of wrongdoing," said Julie Samuels, an intellectual property attorney with the Electronic Frontier Foundation.
Samuels said the judge could order a retrial, but stressed that would be a highly extreme and unlikely scenario.
The case in U.S. District Court, Northern District of California is Oracle America, Inc v. Google Inc, 10-3561.
-
OpenAI has a bold plan to pay for its $1 trillion spending spree: Ads, personal assistants, and cheaper subscriptionsNews OpenAI has lined up more than $1 trillion in spending – and now it's trying to figure out how to pay for it all.
-
Oracle leadership shake-up comes at 'the right moment' as Safra Catz makes way for co-CEOSNews Clay Magouyrk and Mike Silica will take up the joint role at Oracle amidst a sharpened AI focus
-
Oracle layoffs loom despite strong financial resultsNews Hundreds of staff across US and elsewhere say they've been made redundant
-
IBM eyes Oracle expertise gains with latest acquisitionNews The deal aims to help IBM address the complexities of public sector cloud transformation
-
Channel Focus: All you need to know about Oracle's partner programWhat to know about partnering with Oracle: A brief guide to the database management software company as it expands further into cloud solutions
-
‘Many of our long-time rivals are now our partners’: Why Oracle is doubling down on multi-cloudAnalysis The firm is focusing heavily on integration with other major cloud providers to drive multi-cloud adoption for customers
-
SuiteWorld 2024 live: All the news and updates as they happenLive Blog ITPro is live on the ground in Las Vegas today for Oracle SuiteWorld 2024 – follow our rolling coverage to keep tabs on all the latest news and announcements
-
Oracle ditches the hype for a straight talking generative AI approachAnalysis Oracle knows it has to box clever in the generative AI race, and its ambitions rest on delivering tangible enterprise use-cases