IT Pro is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

The metaverse is a waste of time, effort and processing power

If you look closely, this next big digital breakthrough is actually all around us

In a gleaming office in California, Mark Zuckerberg closes his eyes, and dreams of a better world. In this world, people hang out, chat, shop, watch movies and play together, unhampered by distance or time zone. It’s a world in which every creature comfort of modern life is available instantly at our fingertips in digital form. It’s a world where the shimmering spires of corporate-branded ‘experience centres’ stretch all the way to the horizon – and it’s a world that he controls. Mark Zuckerberg dreams of this world, and he smiles.

This hypercapitalist digital utopia is known as ‘the metaverse’ and has been hailed by many as the next evolution in our digital lives, with our online identities being forged into avatars to represent us in virtual worlds, accessed through cutting-edge VR headsets. The entity previously known as Facebook is leading the charge on this, going so far as to change its name to better align itself with the concept, but companies like Nike, Coca Cola, Epic and Gucci are also clamouring to stake their claim on this new frontier.

Except this brave new world isn’t really new. A clip recently did the rounds on social media, purporting to show Walmart’s vision for virtual shopping in the metaverse, but as was quickly pointed out, it’s actually a concept video from several years ago, when functional VR was still a novelty, and brands flocked to take advantage. The same thing happened in the early 2000s, when the short-lived popularity of Second Life led to everyone from Fox and Reuters to Cisco and Sun Microsystems establishing virtual presences within the game. 

Related Resource

A buyer’s guide to board management software

Improve your board’s performance

Whitepaper cover with photo of someone using a tablet

Second Life didn’t reinvent social interaction, and neither will this new vision for the metaverse. This is because what none of the companies trying to jump onto this digital gravy train want to admit is that the concept is flawed on a fundamental level. 

To explain why, we first have to recognise what has made the internet – and its current incarnation in particular – so successful. There are three main pillars on which ‘web 2.0’ is based: convenience, choice and accessibility. The technology to create and consume online content is ubiquitous and affordable, which gives us instant access to a functionally infinite library of goods, services, information and entertainment, no matter what we’re looking for.

Web 3.0, by contrast, misses all three of those marks. Creating a presence in the metaverse currently requires exponentially more time, effort, resources and skills than setting up a web page or social media presence, which means it’s restricted only to the corporate behemoths that can afford it. Consequently, your choices within the metaverse are extremely limited, as are your incentives for engaging with it in the first place. That’s also assuming you have the capability to do so in the first place; many metaverse projects are being planned with VR in mind, which remains prohibitively expensive for most consumers.

A woman using her avatar on Second Life

Getty Images

Second Life, released in 2003, is a real-time immersive social space in which residents can interact with complete freedom 

What’s more, it’s intrinsically less convenient than existing user experiences. Current models for the metaverse most closely resemble a digital equivalent of Disneyworld (another appropriately nightmarish example of unfettered capitalism), with separate areas for different services or activities. Go and visit Nikeland to customise a set of virtual trainers, then head over to the Netflix multiplex to catch a film – that kind of thing. A rather jolly idea, on the surface, but it ignores the fact that I can already do all of that simultaneously, and more besides, with the devices I already have in my pocket and on my desk. 

At this point, it’s important to note the distinction between the idea of the metaverse and the related – but not interdependent – concepts of VR and AR. Both VR and AR have compelling potential use-cases in a number of areas, including collaboration and social interaction, but they don’t need to be built on top of a twee, stylised virtual world to be useful. What they need is a solid framework of back-end technical support and functionality.

The ‘utopian’ vision of the corporate digital future, as presented by companies like Meta, is a fantasy, and a complete boondoggle to boot. For businesses, the cost of entering the metaverse will be enormous, and in a scant handful of years, the digital ruins of those abandoned investments will stand as testament to the futility of trying to recreate what we’ve already got.

We already have a blueprint for the ideal metaverse, and you’re using it right now. Since its inception in science fiction, the idea of the metaverse has been built around bringing everything and everyone in our lives together into one cohesive digital world, and the modern web has already achieved that. It may not be represented by fancy graphical environments or immersive experiences, but it’s brought people and cultures together in ways that Meta’s ‘walled garden’ approach can only dream of. 

More importantly, it’s powered by the one essential element that every virtual world has so far lacked: interoperability. The rise of APIs has given us the ability to combine content and experiences from a huge range of digital services 

The potential to create useful, functional and convenient experiences already rests in the palm of our hands, and it doesn’t require a team of animators and 3D modellers to do it. Instead of remaking the internet to suit the priorities of a handful of tech giants, organisations should instead focus their resources on strengthening the internet we’ve already got, building tools and engaging in true collaboration. To paraphrase Willy Wonka, if you want to view the metaverse, simply look around and view it.

Featured Resources

2022 State of the multi-cloud report

What are the biggest multi-cloud motivations for decision-makers, and what are the leading challenges

Free Download

The Total Economic Impact™ of IBM robotic process automation

Cost savings and business benefits enabled by robotic process automation

Free Download

Multi-cloud data integration for data leaders

A holistic data-fabric approach to multi-cloud integration

Free Download

MLOps and trustworthy AI for data leaders

A data fabric approach to MLOps and trustworthy AI

Free Download

Recommended

MoD taps AWS for skills training amid digital transformation struggle
digital transformation

MoD taps AWS for skills training amid digital transformation struggle

2 Dec 2022
Why Japan finds it so hard to digitally transform
digital transformation

Why Japan finds it so hard to digitally transform

1 Dec 2022
Can your business afford to go serverless?
cloud computing

Can your business afford to go serverless?

30 Nov 2022
Dropbox adds end-to-end, zero-knowledge encryption with acquisition of Boxcryptor assets
mergers and acquisitions

Dropbox adds end-to-end, zero-knowledge encryption with acquisition of Boxcryptor assets

30 Nov 2022

Most Popular

Empowering employees to truly work anywhere
Sponsored

Empowering employees to truly work anywhere

22 Nov 2022
How to boot Windows 11 in Safe Mode
Microsoft Windows

How to boot Windows 11 in Safe Mode

15 Nov 2022
The top 12 password-cracking techniques used by hackers
Security

The top 12 password-cracking techniques used by hackers

14 Nov 2022