Police officers say IT system glitches responsible ‘for letting criminals off’
Frequent crashes and a frustrating user experience underpin a system that’s “made an impossible job unbearable”


An IT system used by nine police forces across England and Wales is blighted with frequent crashes and is overly-bureaucratic to the extent it is slowing down the criminal justice system.
Officers speaking with the BBC's Victoria Derbyshire Show under the condition of anonymity accused the Athena platform, developed by Northgate Public Services, of creating problems due to a host of glitches.
"The first two weeks we had Athena brought in were probably the worst two weeks in my entire career. It has made an impossible job unbearable," one officer told the programme.
"It's overly bureaucratic. It doesn't understand the police investigative process at all. From day one, it malfunctioned. Four years on, it is still malfunctioning"
A range of problems can be traced to issues with the IT system, according to the officers, such as cases having to be dropped, or detainees missing their medication due to staff being unable to access their records.
It also often asks for data points that are totally irrelevant, such as the gender of an assigned solicitor, which if missed can lead to the whole case being rejected. Some cases, such as minor assaults, have had to be dropped due to the inadequacies of the system.
Meanwhile, processing a simple shoplifting incident exemplifies its sluggishness, according to one officer, as they would "have to press about 50 buttons, with a 30-second minimum loading time between each task".
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
Another police officer said: "It slows the whole criminal justice system down. At the moment, it is not fit for purpose. This is the most challenging time I have come across. We're at breaking point already. This has pushed some officers over the edge."
The Athena platform is just one of a multiplicity of IT systems deployed by police forces across the country and is understood to have cost 35 million over the last ten years.
The state of police IT previously came under fire in a report published by the Home Affairs Select Committee in 2011, which compared the digital landscape at the time to that of "an adolescent's bedroom".
The main reason for this is that the UK's 43 independent forces had a host of varied IT systems and IT contracts between them all.
IT Pro approached the Home Office and Northgate Public Services for comment.

Keumars Afifi-Sabet is a writer and editor that specialises in public sector, cyber security, and cloud computing. He first joined ITPro as a staff writer in April 2018 and eventually became its Features Editor. Although a regular contributor to other tech sites in the past, these days you will find Keumars on LiveScience, where he runs its Technology section.
-
Blackouts in Spain and Portugal could be a cyber attack
Both countries are "paralyzed" by nationwide power outages
By Jane McCallion
-
Cisco takes aim at AI security at RSAC with ServiceNow partnership
News The companies claim Cisco AI Defense and ServiceNow SecOps will help address new challenges raised by AI
By Jane McCallion
-
Better together
Whitepaper Achieve more with Windows 11 and Surface
By ITPro
-
Transforming the enterprise
Whitepaper With Intel and CDW
By ITPro
-
The top trends in money remittance
Whitepaper Tackling the key issues shaping the money remittance industry
By ITPro
-
How Kantar revamped its IT infrastructure after being sold off
Case Study Being acquired by a private equity firm meant Kantar couldn’t rely on its parent company’s infrastructure, and was forced to confront its technical shortcomings
By Rene Millman
-
Deutsche Bank wraps up Postbank IT integration after bug-laden migrations
News The IT merger is expected to generate annual savings of €300 million by 2025
By Daniel Todd
-
Analyzing the economic benefits of Dell Technologies with VMware Tanzu & Intel
Whitepaper ESG economic validation
By ITPro
-
Defra needs £726 million to modernize pervasive legacy IT issues
News A significant portion of IT systems are reportedly still in extended support or are fully unsupported
By Ross Kelly
-
Former TSB CIO fined £81,000 for botched IT migration
News It’s the first penalty imposed on an individual involved in the infamous migration project
By Ross Kelly