Trump wants to dismiss lawsuit targeting social media order

Administration calls CDT lawsuit a “profound misunderstanding”

The Trump administration has filed a motion asking a court to dismiss a lawsuit against an executive order targeting social media companies. According to a copy of the motion, which Reuters saw, the Trump administration has called it a "profound misunderstanding".

In May, President Trump issued an executive order targeting social media companies and Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act. The order was issued just days after Twitter fact-checked one of the President’s tweets regarding mail-in voting. 

In response to the executive order, the Washington-based tech group Center for Democracy and Technology (CDT), which is funded by Facebook, Google and Twitter, filed a lawsuit arguing the executive order violates the First Amendment rights of social media companies and will ultimately hinder free online speech.

The Trump administration, however, says that the executive order isn’t directing private companies to moderate their content.

"The EO challenged here imposes no obligations on any private party," said the motion filed by the Department of Justice in the US District Court for the District of Columbia, which was seen by Reuters.

"It directs executive officials to take steps that could lead various agencies to examine ... allegations that large social media online platforms have displayed political bias in moderating content," the motion claims.

Avery Gardiner, CDT’s general counsel, said of the motion: "Instead of actually trying to address the merits of the issues, and to engage in litigation that will show the severe constitutional deformities of the executive order, it is resorting to legal maneuvering."

Gardiner added that CDT has negotiated a briefing schedule with the Department of Justice and will be filing its response by the end of August. The government will likely respond by September 21, she said.

White House spokesman Judd Deere claims, though, that the Trump administration moved to dismiss the case because “it is not a valid legal argument.”

"The left-wing lobbying organization’s brief seems to suggest it doesn’t understand how administrative action works or possibly that it doesn’t understand the nature of the judicial system," he told Reuters. 

Last month, the US Commerce Department also petitioned the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to clarify "when online platforms can claim section 230 protections if they restrict access to content in a manner not specifically outlined under the Act." In response, FCC Chairman Ajit Pai agreed to open the petition to public comment for 45 days.

Featured Resources

Five lessons learned from the pivot to a distributed workforce

Delivering continuity and scale with a remote work strategy

Download now

Connected experiences in a digital transformation

Enable businesses to meet the demands of the future

Download now

Simplify to secure

Reduce complexity by integrating your security ecosystem

Download now

Enhance the safety and security of your people, assets and operations

Enable a true vision of security with an engineered solution based on hyperconverged and storage platforms

Download now

Recommended

Ban on TikTok and WeChat downloads begin Sunday
Policy & legislation

Ban on TikTok and WeChat downloads begin Sunday

18 Sep 2020
ByteDance says China must approve Oracle's TikTok deal
Acquisition

ByteDance says China must approve Oracle's TikTok deal

17 Sep 2020
Oracle and TikTok deal close, but ByteDance wants majority ownership
mergers and acquisitions

Oracle and TikTok deal close, but ByteDance wants majority ownership

16 Sep 2020
TikTok gets a new competitor, YouTube Shorts
social media

TikTok gets a new competitor, YouTube Shorts

15 Sep 2020

Most Popular

Google Pixel 4a review: A picture-perfect package
Google Android

Google Pixel 4a review: A picture-perfect package

18 Sep 2020
Accenture ploughs $3 billion into cloud migration support group
digital transformation

Accenture ploughs $3 billion into cloud migration support group

17 Sep 2020
16 ways to speed up your laptop
Laptops

16 ways to speed up your laptop

16 Sep 2020