Surface Pro 3 vs ElitePad 1000 head-to-head review
Which Windows 8 tablet is the best?
Display & Pen input
Sub-10in devices such as the iPad mini and Nexus 7 have become popular, but for optimal productivity larger screens are favoured.
Microsoft has opted for a 12in display with a unique 3:2 ratio, so the Pro 3 has the dimension of an A43 diary/notebook.
The Pro 3 has a sublime display. The 2160 x 1440 resolution means pictures, video and text are all razor-sharp. Colours are deep and it's great for display high-res images and video. We clocked the maximum brightness at 352cd/m2. And, although the screen has a glossy finish it wasn't overly affected by glare as we were able to adjust the kickstand.
HP has used a smaller 10.1in display with a 1900 x 1200 resolution. This means it has over one million less pixels so it's not as sharp. Colours on the ElitePad appear washed-out and it's got a maximum brightness of 292cd/m2.
Both devices are a good size for web browsing. However, they also have scaling issues with third-party apps such as Photoshop, which have not been optimised for the high pixel resolutions.
Pen input is available on both the Pro 3 and ElitePad 1000. HP and Microsoft have crafted metallic pens to give them the look and weight of a traditional writing implement.
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2026 report - the leading resource for IT decision-maker insight on priorities and investment areas in AI, security and more.
The pens each support 256 points of pressure and require a AAA battery. Microsoft's pen is supplied in the box, whereas HP sells it separately.
Microsoft has the edge as it has designed the pen on the Surface Pro 3 to sync with its OneNote application. Pressing the button on top of the pen opens up OneNote so you can start jotting notes straight away. Click the pen again and it will save the note and open up a new page. By giving the pen lid a double tap, you can print screen the page and then annotate it.
This is an excellent implementation, which works even when the device is locked and in sleep mode. So, for example, if you were in a meeting or lecture and suddenly wanted to jot something interesting it's possible to do so just like you had a piece of paper in front of you.
Winner: Surface Pro 3. The display is brighter with more vibrant colours and the pen implementation is the best we've seen on a tablet.
Khidr Suleman was the Technical Editor at IT Pro and during his time with the site was responsible for the reviews section. Prior to joining IT Pro, Khidr worked as a reporter at Incisive Media. He studied law at the University of Reading and completed a Postgraduate Diploma in Magazine Journalism and Online Writing at PMA Training.
-
ITPro is 20!We take a look back on the past two decades since ITPro launched...
-
Cyber experts issue alert after two ransomware groups team up on ‘unprecedented’ threat campaignNews The tie-up includes a new model of industrialized ransomware deployment that significantly lowers the barrier to entry for cyber crime
-
How immersive does a video meeting really need to be?Opinion It’s time to accept that virtual business meetings are awful and no amount of innovation will make them more engaging
-
HP reveals Microsoft licensing management service for SMBsNews The company wants to make it easier for small businesses to manage their cloud-based subscriptions
-
Tech giants lobby US to fund chip productionNews Industry heavyweights ask Congress for $50 billion in chip manufacturing subsidies
-
HP Pro c640 Chromebook review: Nailing the basicsReviews While it’s a pleasure to type with, this device is let down by several serious weaknesses
-
The IT Pro Products of the Year 2019: All the year’s best hardwareBest Our favourite equipment from the past 12 months