Amazon & Snapchat ranked bottom for government requests
Apple, Facebook, Google and Yahoo applauded for protecting user data
Amazon and Snapchat have been ranked among the worst companies for protecting users' data from government requests.
The findings have come in the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF)'s Who Has Your Back? report, based around analysing the reactions of companies ordered to pass sensitive data over to governments.
All technology firms have different processes when it comes to protecting data, highlighting the need for an industry standard response.
The companies tested receive a "gold star" if they adhered to any one of six standards for data protection: requiring a warrant, telling users about requests, publishing transparency reports, publishing law guidelines, fighting for users' rights in court and fighting for their rights in the US Congress.
The results come in stark contrast to the details contained in the PRISM leaks
Snapchat placed dead-last with just one star. The firm publishes law enforcement guidelines but nothing else. Any user whose data is requested by the government will not be informed.
Above Snapchat but still rated only two stars are Amazon and US telecoms company AT&T. The retail giant's awards stemmed from its warrants for data and protecting its users in court. AT&T received two stars for publishing both law enforcement guidelines and transparency reports.
A number of companies improved their support for their customer base and took steps towards protecting their users data from intrusions and mining. The results come in stark contrast to the details of the PRISM leaks, which claimed prominent technology companies had been working with agencies in the colection of user data.
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2026 report - the leading resource for IT decision-maker insight on priorities and investment areas in AI, security and more.
A measure taken by big tech firms in the wake of the leaks was to begin publishing transparency reports, one of the catergories that the EFF counts.
"The sunlight brought about by a year's worth of Snowden leaks appears to have prompted dozens of companies to improve their policies when it comes to giving user data to the government," Raiey Reitman, activism director at the EFF, told The Guardian.
Apple and Yahoo received the highest praise from the EFF, gaining the full six-star rating. Yahoo specifically won praise for fighting for user privacy in the US foreign intelligence surveillance court.
Facebook has greatly improved its standards, jumping from one star in 2011 to six stars 2014, despite founder Mark Zuckerberg's previous stance that privacy on the internet was "dead".
-
TfL takes Oyster photocard systems offline following breachNews Security experts warn the Oyster photocard breach could lead to follow-up attacks on victims
-
Irish credit unions hit by data breach after IT provider compromisedNews Wellington IT reportedly delayed alerting customers by multiple weeks
-
‘Hugely significant’: Experts welcome UK government plans to back down in Apple encryption battle – but it’s not quite over yetNews Tulsi Gabbard, US director of national intelligence, has confirmed the UK plans to back down on plans that would see Apple forced to create a "back door" for authorities.
-
‘A huge national security risk’: Thousands of government laptops, tablets, and phones are missing and nowhere to be foundNews A freedom of information disclosure shows more than 2,000 government-issued phones, tablets, and laptops have been lost or stolen, prompting huge cybersecurity concerns.
-
The UK cybersecurity sector is worth over £13 billion, but experts say there’s huge untapped potential if it can overcome these hurdlesAnalysis A new report released by the DSIT revealed the UK’s cybersecurity sector generated £13.2 billion over the last year
-
2022 Public Sector Identity Index ReportWhitepaper UK Report
-
UK and Japan strike digital partnership to collaborate on IoT security, semiconductorsNews The two countries are also set to align their approaches to digital regulation to make it easier for companies to operate in each nation
-
UK government puts Online Safety Bill 'on ice'News Delaying the third reading until the autumn gives the next prime minister and digital secretary a chance to revise, or throw out, the legislation
-
Online Safety Bill: Messaging apps 'forced to scan messages' for child abuse content in fresh amendmentNews Apps utilising end-to-end encryption would require backdoors or new mechanisms to allow user data to be scanned and passed on to authorities
-
UK signs first post-Brexit data pact with South KoreaNews Data-dependent trade between the two nations is worth £1.33 billion, and the government hopes the deal will open up new markets for digital trade