ACTA legality set for EU court scrutiny
The European Court of Justice is being asked to look into the legality of the controversial parts of ACTA.
The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has been asked today to rule on the legality of the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA).
Comissioner Karel De Gucht said the European Commission was planning to ask Europe's highest court to "asses whether ACTA is incompatible in any way with the EU's fundamental rights and freedoms."
The European Commission has already passed ACTA to national governments for ratification, however, while the Council has unanimously adopted ACTA and authorised member states to sign the agreement.
So far, the agreement has been signed by 22 member states.
ACTA has given rise to concern among the European public, with protests being held across the continent in opposition to the agreement. in particular, there is a growing concern about internet censorship and loss of freedoms of speech and expression.
If the Commission expects these protests about clumsy and dangerous internet policies to fade away, they are very much mistaken.
De Gucht said this was something the EC recognised.
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2026 report - the leading resource for IT decision-maker insight on priorities and investment areas in AI, security and more.
"Let me be very clear: I share people's concern for these fundamental freedoms," he said.
"I welcome that people have voiced their concerns so actively especially over the freedom of the internet. And I also understand that there is uncertainty on what ACTA will really mean for these key issues at the end of the day.
"I believe that putting ACTA before the European Court of Justice is a needed step. This debate must be based upon facts and not upon the misinformation or rumour that has dominated social media sites and blogs in recent weeks."
Vice president of the European Commission, Viviane Reding, explained in a statement that freedoms of expression, speech and intellectual property are fundamental EU rights.
"Intellectual property is also a fundamental right recognised by the EU's Charter of Fundamental Rights," Reding said.
"European policy therefore should aim at mutually balancing the respect for both fundamental rights, without calling into question their essence. Freedom of information and intellectual property rights must not be enemies; they should be partners."
De Gacht still took time to defend ACTA, however.
"So let me be clear: ACTA will change nothing about how we use the internet and social websites today since it does not introduce any new rules. ACTA only helps to enforce what is already law today," he said.
"ACTA will not censor websites or shut them down; ACTA will not hinder freedom of the internet or freedom of speech."
The European Publisher's Council (ECP) has released a statement backing the plans to ratify ACTA.
"Failure to ratify ACTA would jeopardise the future of secure copyright protection at EU level just at the moment when the European Commission is about to review the copyright directive," said Angela Mills Wade, executive director of the EPC.
However, De Gachts argument has not convinced everyone. Peter Bradwell of the Open Rights Group was concerned the EC was simply buying time with today's announcement.
"The European Commission has a vested interest in seeing ACTA pass. They get to choose the question asked of the Court. They show every sign of making sure they get the answers they want to try to give ACTA a fig leaf of legitimacy," Bradwell said.
"And this is also clearly an attempt by the Commission to pause the ratification process in the hope that protests lose their heat."
Bradwell insisted that the resistance to ACTA will continue.
"If the Commission expects these protests about clumsy and dangerous internet policies to fade away, they are very much mistaken. Citizens across Europe have found their voice," he said.
-
UK tech leaders are implementing AI faster than related governanceNews IBM research shows that chief AI officers are being given strategy roles, but not full control
-
11:11 Systems appoints new EVP in EMEA growth driveNews The experienced executive will oversee the provider’s operations and strategic execution across the region as it targets further growth
-
EU can't afford sovereign cloud, research claimsCiting costs that it claims have been overlooked, CCIA Europe is predicting a €115 billion bill.
-
ISACA CEO says AI compliance will be like 'SOX on steroids'News Businesses will need to do far more work in far less time to meet stringent regulations
-
Three things you need to know about the new EU AI Act rulesNews From this week, organizations operating in the EU have a new set of obligations around AI content and transparency
-
Startup founders lament 'regulatory friction' despite EU simplification effortsNews Entrepreneurs are spending a fortune on compliance, and it’s forcing some to consider relocating
-
AWS says cloud market gatekeeper designation risks ‘deterring European investment and innovation’ as EU regulators plot competition crackdownNews Gatekeeper designation under the legislation would force AWS and Microsoft to make concessions
-
‘This closes a gap that has caused real uncertainty in the market’: Changes to EU AI Act implementation deadlines welcomed by industryNews New implementation deadlines for the EU AI Act could help remove “genuine friction” for European companies
-
‘Reducing reliance on foreign tech infrastructure is key’ to European tech success – and its survivalNews MEPs have once again called for decreased reliance on foreign tech infrastructure
-
EU inaugurates NanoIC facility for next-generation chipsNews The project forms part of efforts to reduce reliance on US and Asian supply chains