Return to office mandates can be divisive - here are three things business leaders can do to help smooth the transition
With return to office mandates having sparked major spats between workers and employers, leaders need to consider how they can make changes attractive and effective


Strict return to office (RTO) mandates have become a major flashpoint for organizations in recent months, but it doesn’t have to be this way, experts have told ITPro.
Research from both Gartner and Randstad UK has highlighted the correlation between strict return to office mandates and employee satisfaction. Gartner’s research, released at the end of January, found that employee intent to stay among average employees was 8% lower with RTO mandates and 16% lower among high-performing employees.
Meanwhile, Randstad UK found that, out of 2,000 surveyed employees, more than half (54%) of workers described the ability to work from home as “non-negotiable.”
The argument on both sides can often be linked to productivity, but is often conflicting. The National Bureau of Economic Research suggested that “Information Workers” were 18% less productive when working fully remote, while 59% of workers told RingCentral that they felt more productive in a remote setting.
While businesses may want to push workers back into the office, they also need to avoid pushing workers away altogether.
With staff vocally prioritizing a relaxed approach to RTO policies, then, businesses should ask themselves what a successful RTO process entails.
“To prevent employee attrition, HR leaders should avoid rigid RTO mandates and instead seek to implement RTO strategies that maximize talent and business outcomes,” Garnter said.
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
Return to office policies should motivate, not mandate
Businesses should prioritize the rewards of in-office working, rather than threatening the punishments of remaining remote.
Some businesses, such as Google, have opted for the former, with the tech giant introducing measures that would include office attendance levels as part of performance reviews. This came after a flurry of spats between Google and its staff over enforced RTO measures.
RELATED WHITEPAPER
Opting for the latter, on the other hand, could bring about huge benefits for employee satisfaction, according to Michael Doolin, CEO of Clover HR. Speaking to ITPro, Doolin said business leaders should help foster an environment in which firms don’t have to fight tooth and nail to enforce TRO policies. In doing this, staff will naturally warm to them.
“Whilst it’s not unreasonable to expect employees to return to the office, it’s important to recognise that the environment has changed, and things may never return to the previous norm,” he said.
Doolin added that the office setting needs to be adapted. It needs to be optimized for the return of those who may feel discouraged by RTO, or those who have been fully remote for a long time.
“This might even include things like preferred office layout,” he added. “Remember, a physical return can be difficult, so offering professional mental health support can ease the process.
Staff need to be part of the policy conversation
RTO is far from a one-size fits all situation, and businesses need to respect that.
Individual mandates need to work for individual employees. While companies at large have certain requirements, whether in the form of productivity projections or office guidelines, individual workers also have their own requirements.
“Leaders are constantly navigating demands between the collective and the individual,” Emma O’Connor, director and head of HR training at Boyes Turner, told ITPro.
“While managers are looking at what’s best for the business, employees are asking “How do I want to work?” she added. “The how, when, and where can become a point of conflict.”
Each employee situation and each business is different, so flexibility makes sense on both sides of the equation. Decision makers need to pursue RTO policies which can be tailored as part of ongoing conversations between employee and employer.
“While it might be better for an employee with two school-aged kids to work from home, we find more Gen Z colleagues want to be in the office – for support, encouragement and mentoring as much as the social considerations,” O’Connor added.
“There must be flexibility both ways.”
Employers need to be transparent about requirements
According to Gartner, organizations that transparently communicated their reasoning for wanting employees to return to the office saw “positive impacts on engagement, discretionary effort, and retention.”
Transparency is always key to motivation, though this is especially true in the case of a remote workforce which, up and until the implementation of an RTO mandate, will have had no reason to come back to the office.
Providing these workers with clear, transparent reasons for returning to the office is vital if organizations want any sort of success with their RTO mandates.
Microsoft, for example, pointed to its own research, suggesting that remote working policies led to a decrease in collaboration and community.
The bottom line was, of course, that employees should head back into the office in order to reap the social benefits.

George Fitzmaurice is a former Staff Writer at ITPro and ChannelPro, with a particular interest in AI regulation, data legislation, and market development. After graduating from the University of Oxford with a degree in English Language and Literature, he undertook an internship at the New Statesman before starting at ITPro. Outside of the office, George is both an aspiring musician and an avid reader.
-
Cisco takes aim at AI security at RSAC with ServiceNow partnership
News The companies claim Cisco AI Defense and ServiceNow SecOps will help address new challenges raised by AI
By Jane McCallion
-
Why veterans can excel in data centers – and could help the IT sector address its skill shortages
In-depth Ex-military workers can bring software and hardware to civilian roles
By John Loeppky
-
Google tells some remote workers to return to the office or risk losing jobs
News Google has warned remote workers will need to return to the office or else lose their jobs, according to reports.
By Ross Kelly
-
Google breakup plans would ‘hurt America’s consumers, economy, and technological leadership’, senior exec claims
News Google has struck back against US regulators, claiming that plans to dismantle the company would "hurt the economy".
By Nicole Kobie
-
Google faces 'first of its kind' class action for search ads overcharging in UK
News Google faces a "first of its kind" £5 billion lawsuit in the UK over accusations it has a monopoly in digital advertising that allows it to overcharge customers.
By Nicole Kobie
-
Google just released a new AI agent for data scientists on Colab, and it’s free to use
News Google Labs has made Data Science Agent available to all Colab users in a bid to help developers speed up application design.
By Emma Woollacott
-
‘Europe could do it, but it's chosen not to do it’: Eric Schmidt thinks EU regulation will stifle AI innovation – but Britain has a huge opportunity
News Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt believes EU AI regulation is hampering innovation in the region and placing enterprises at a disadvantage.
By Ross Kelly
-
Google Cloud names new VP for UK&I and Sub-Saharan Africa
News The experienced executive will lead Google Cloud's operations and sales strategy across the two regions
By Daniel Todd
-
Google wants regulators to break up Microsoft's OpenAI deal
News Google has already been nipping at Microsoft’s heels in the European cloud market over competition concerns
By George Fitzmaurice
-
DoJ demands Google sells Chrome — and potentially Android too
News Confirming earlier reports, the US Department of Justice filing calls for Chrome to be divested over monopoly concerns
By Emma Woollacott