A decade-long ban on AI laws is a “terrible idea” for everyone but big tech, critics claim
Critics say sneaking a ban on state-level AI regulation into a spending bill is a bad move
A proposed decade-long ban on US states implementing AI laws is a "terrible idea" that highlights the scale of big tech lobbying, according to critics.
Earlier this week, a Republican-led committee proposed a budget reconciliation bill which at the last minute tucked within its pages a clause that would ban state-level AI regulation for the next ten years. If approved, only the US Congress could legislate on AI, not state governments.
The bill included a line that said "no State or political subdivision thereof may enforce any law or regulation regulating artificial intelligence models, artificial intelligence systems, or automated decision systems during the 10-year period of this Act."
That would preempt efforts by California and other states looking to rein in AI using regulation. It remains to be seen if the section will be included in the final bill and whether that will be passed.
Following the move, the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) published a statement strongly opposing the proposals, calling it a "terrible idea".
The EFF noted that it would override existing state laws designed to prevent people from harms caused by AI and would prevent other states from writing similar legislation — a problem as Congress is much slower at taking on new technologies.
Similarly, the non-profit said this risks no regulation being implemented at all for ten years during a critical time in the development of the technology.
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2026 report - the leading resource for IT decision-maker insight on priorities and investment areas in AI, security and more.
"Even if Congress does nothing on AI for the next ten years, this would still prevent states from stepping into the breach," the EFF said in a statement. "Given how different the AI industry looks now from how it looked just three years ago, it’s hard to even conceptualize how different it may look in ten years."
"Congress does not react quickly and, particularly when addressing harms from emerging technologies, has been far slower to act than states,” the EFF added.
Wider criticism
An open letter signed by a series of state-level representatives — as well as frequent AI dissenter and New York University professor Gary Marcus — made a similar argument, calling the attempt to preempt AI laws "deeply problematic".
"If enacted, the statute would preempt states from acting — even if AI systems cause measurable harm, such as through discriminatory lending, unsafe autonomous vehicles, or invasive workplace surveillance," the letter added.
Other critics made it clear the move was seen as benefiting big tech. Lee Hepner, senior legal counsel at the American Economic Liberties Project, described the move as a “sweeping and reckless attempt” to shield large corporations from accountability.
Why ban AI laws?
A ten-year ban on AI laws may sound inherently extreme, but those in favor of it argue that AI regulation requires a national approach to minimize the costs and impact of regulation at a time when the US is battling China for dominance in this domain.
An article in Lawfare argued that the current “patchwork of parochial regulatory policies” could severely undermine US innovation in the AI space at a critical juncture.
But the open letter noted that presented a "false choice" between too many laws and a single set of federal laws, given there was effectively zero of the latter.
"If Washington wants to pass a comprehensive privacy or AI law with teeth, more power to them, but we all know this is unlikely," the letter added.
At a state-level, there are dozens of examples of AI laws — from Colorado's AI protection bill to California's attempts to rein in its own industry.
"It's specifically because of state momentum that Big Tech is trying to shut the states down," the letter added.
The EFF echoed that: "As the big technology companies have done (and continue to do) with privacy legislation, AI companies are currently going all out to slow or roll back legal protections in states."
MORE FROM ITPRO
- Is the UK falling behind the EU on AI regulation?
- American tech workers want AI regulation – but they might have to wait a while
- Why AI could be a legal nightmare for years to come
Freelance journalist Nicole Kobie first started writing for ITPro in 2007, with bylines in New Scientist, Wired, PC Pro and many more.
Nicole the author of a book about the history of technology, The Long History of the Future.
-
Know your Microsoft 365 data, trust your recoveryHow contextual intelligence helps IT teams reduce ROT, protect sensitive content, and govern AI access
-
Five ways CISOs can use ‘dark AI’ to their own advantageIn-Depth Vulnerability discovery will explode over the next few years, but CIOs can use AI to beat hackers at their own game
-
‘This is a massive change’: PagerDuty wants to supercharge incident response with a new SRE agent and command centerNews The new Paige agent from PagerDuty will act as a digital assistant for teams battling incidents
-
‘Organizations will not generate cost savings from AI at this point’: Just 3% of companies have recorded cost savings with AI – but that isn’t stopping them from investing moreNews More than one-third of AI projects have run over budget, but business leaders are still bullish on investment
-
A big tech taskforce has unveiled a blueprint for UK AI leadership – but time for action is running outNews Success depends on deeper collaboration between government, industry, local leaders and communities
-
Microsoft says AI is causing a workforce rupture among British businesses – leaders are backing the technology, but workers still aren’t soldNews New Microsoft research shows a huge disconnect between leadership and employees when it comes to confidence in the UK leading in AI
-
ISACA CEO says AI compliance will be like 'SOX on steroids'News Businesses will need to do far more work in far less time to meet stringent regulations
-
‘The most useful thing a leader can do right now is admit the plan is unfinished’: Workers are being told to use AI, but not why to use it – here’s why that mattersNews A Culture Amp survey shows workers are eager for AI tools, but they'd like to know the business goal of the technology
-
AI skills investment could boost the UK economy by £80 billion – but there's still a long way to go before firms can capitalize on the technologyNews Researchers are calling for a Skills Tax Credit to incentivize employers
-
An AI kill switch ‘only solves half the problem’ with national security – British firms need to reduce reliance on foreign techNews Efforts to protect national security are welcomed, but bolstering sovereignty is also required