Ex White House CIO attacks insurance firms for 'fuelling ransomware industry'
Theresa Payton argues companies are manipulating victims to avoid paying higher bills


Former CIO of the White House Theresa Payton has warned that cyber insurance companies are supporting the ransomware industry by manipulating organisations into paying to have their systems returned after a cyber attack.
Insurance companies, according to Payton, are encouraging customers to pay ransomware demands as the costs associated with data recovery often outweigh those incurred by the ransom, meaning insurance providers pay far less as a result.
"I'm increasingly frustrated at the trend where the insurance companies are encouraging the victims to pay," said Theresa Payton, former White House CIO and security authority.
"The insurance company looks at what the potential incident response and forensics bill might be and that's going to be bigger in many cases because many organisations are not prepared and they would actually rather pay," she said.
Speaking at CloudSec 2019 in London, Payton said she was recently approached by an organisation seeking advice on how to proceed after its insurance company attempted to handle the ransomware issue directly. In that case, the insurance firm said it was "experienced at negotiating with the ransomware syndicates" and that it could "get the price to go way down".
However, Payton argued that it's important to trust your playbook, which typically tells an organisation not to pay and subsequently fund cyber crime. She added that if an insurance company tells you to pay, it could be an indicator that they're trying to save money.
Ransomware is typically pitched to victims at a slightly lower cost than what it would take to recover, which has been one of the reasons why it has proved to be such a highly successful form of cyber attack over recent years. However, in addition to concerns about funding cyber criminals, organisations are generally advised not to agree to any ransomware payments as there is no guarantee that paying the demand will result in the decryption of files.
Get the ITPro daily newsletter
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
Days prior to the successful coordinated ransomware attack on 22 Texas state municipalities, Payton was in Texas with small municipal and county groups advising on cyber security when an insurance company attempted to convince a security officer that they could be up and running within a day if they paid a ransom.
"I'm like: 'how', that's not how this works," said Payton. "It's not like buying on Amazon and a drone drops off the key - it doesn't work that way."
The 22 Texas municipalities were the most recent targets in a string of ransomware attacks on US state infrastructure since the start of the year. Starting in Baltimore, a series of other small government bodies across the country have been successfully infected with ransomware with many paying their respective ransoms.
Payton suggested the attacks are taking advantage of outdated systems and underfunding.
"At the city county and even the state-level in some cases, they're still dealing with legacy technology," she said. "It's taxpayer dollars that are required to pull in to do modernisation efforts and taxpayers don't see the cloud, they don't see the other things.
"They want their mobile app that lets them get their permit to do the remodelling on their house, but they don't see how their money goes to protect infrastructure."
She said that most of the technology has gone end of life and so many systems are no longer receiving vendor security updates.
Payton's warning follows a report issued earlier this year that showed ransomware attacks on UK businesses soared 195% in 2019 following a reduction in 2018.

Connor Jones has been at the forefront of global cyber security news coverage for the past few years, breaking developments on major stories such as LockBit’s ransomware attack on Royal Mail International, and many others. He has also made sporadic appearances on the ITPro Podcast discussing topics from home desk setups all the way to hacking systems using prosthetic limbs. He has a master’s degree in Magazine Journalism from the University of Sheffield, and has previously written for the likes of Red Bull Esports and UNILAD tech during his career that started in 2015.
-
What is polymorphic malware?
Explainer Polymorphic malware constantly changes its code to avoid detection, making it a top cybersecurity threat that demands advanced, behavior-based defenses
-
Outgoing Kaseya CEO teases "this is just the beginning" for the company
Opinion We spoke to Fred Voccola who remains a key figurehead at the firm as it enters its next chapter...
-
Ransomware attacks are rising — but quiet payouts could mean there's more than actually reported
News Ransomware attacks continue to climb, but they may be even higher than official figures show as companies choose to quietly pay to make such incidents go away.
-
Cleo attack victim list grows as Hertz confirms customer data stolen – and security experts say it won't be the last
News Hertz has confirmed it suffered a data breach as a result of the Cleo zero-day vulnerability in late 2024, with the car rental giant warning that customer data was stolen.
-
‘Phishing kits are a force multiplier': Cheap cyber crime kits can be bought on the dark web for less than $25 – and experts warn it’s lowering the barrier of entry for amateur hackers
News Research from NordVPN shows phishing kits are now widely available on the dark web and via messaging apps like Telegram, and are often selling for less than $25.
-
Healthcare systems are rife with exploits — and ransomware gangs have noticed
News Nearly nine-in-ten healthcare organizations have medical devices that are vulnerable to exploits, and ransomware groups are taking notice.
-
Alleged LockBit developer extradited to the US
News A Russian-Israeli man has been extradited to the US amid accusations of being a key LockBit ransomware developer.
-
February was the worst month on record for ransomware attacks – and one threat group had a field day
News February 2025 was the worst month on record for the number of ransomware attacks, according to new research from Bitdefender.
-
CISA issues warning over Medusa ransomware after 300 victims from critical sectors impacted
News The Medusa ransomware as a Service operation compromised twice as many organizations at the start of 2025 compared to 2024
-
Warning issued over prolific 'Ghost' ransomware group
News The Ghost ransomware group is known to act fast and exploit vulnerabilities in public-facing appliances