HP-owned Autonomy inflated accounts before acquisition
According to emails presented to a court in California last week, the company was heading towards a financial "plane crash"
The HP-Autonomy saga has entered a new phase, with fresh details emerging of what went on at the Cambridge-based software house before the hardware giant snapped it up.
The former management team at Autonomy has been embroiled in a court case against HP for some time now, with the computer manufacturer claiming the company's founder falsified accounts to present an inflated value before acquisition.
Software company Autonomy was acquired in 2011 by HP for $11.7bn (7.16bn), but after a year of operation, revenues from the company started dropping considerably.
In 2012, HP filed action against Autonomy, citing "serious accounting improprieties" and "outright misrepresentations". In August, a settlement deal was rejected by a United States district court judge and the latest development has seen HP present evidence to the courts.
The evidence was presented by HP's lawyer Marc Wolinsky, including an email from Autonomy's finance director Sushovan Hussain to founder Mike Lynch, sent at 1.19am on 10 December 2010, three weeks before the end of Autonomy's financial year. The email read: "Really don't know what to do mike. As I guessed revenue fell away completely.
"We've covered up with bofa and hopefully db and Doi but if latter two don't happen it's totally bad. There are swathes of reps with nothing to do maybe chase imaginary deals."
'Bofa' refers to the Bank of America Merrill Lynch, one of the Autonomy's clients at the time. The panicked email was triggered by the poor performance of the company's IDOL product.
Sign up today and you will receive a free copy of our Future Focus 2025 report - the leading guidance on AI, cybersecurity and other IT challenges as per 700+ senior executives
HP said in the court filings: "HP did not miss the fraud at Autonomy because it wasn't diligent enough. The problem was Autonomy executives had lied. Repeatedly."
The company is trying to settle damages claims from shareholders relating to breach of fiduciary duty by its directors, including chief executive Meg Whitman. Following the acquisition, HP was forced to write down non-hardware revenues by 24 per cent because of bad performance.
HP is also trying to file claims against Autonomy's auditor Deloitte over claims it signed off accounts filled with "misrepresentations and outright falsehoods".

Clare is the founder of Blue Cactus Digital, a digital marketing company that helps ethical and sustainability-focused businesses grow their customer base.
Prior to becoming a marketer, Clare was a journalist, working at a range of mobile device-focused outlets including Know Your Mobile before moving into freelance life.
As a freelance writer, she drew on her expertise in mobility to write features and guides for ITPro, as well as regularly writing news stories on a wide range of topics.
-
What does modern security success look like for financial services?Sponsored As financial institutions grapple with evolving cyber threats, intensifying regulations, and the limitations of ageing IT infrastructure, the need for a resilient and forward-thinking security strategy has never been greater
-
Yes, legal AI. But what can you actually do with it? Let’s take a look…Sponsored Legal AI is a knowledge multiplier that can accelerate research, sharpen insights, and organize information, provided legal teams have confidence in its transparent and auditable application
-
The HP ZBook Ultra G1a offers truly impressive levels of performance – a genuine game-changerReviews AMD's new Ryzen AI Max+ 395 redefines what we can expect from a laptop chipset with an integrated GPU and delivers outstanding performance
-
The HP ZBook X G1i is a full-throttle juggernaut – you couldn't ask for much more from a workstationReviews The HP ZBook X G1i offers almost everything you could want from a workstation, and it's delightful to use
-
HP ZBook 8 G1ak 14 review: Plenty of promise but falls shortReviews This portable mobile workstation promises so much but fails to deliver in a few key quarters – meaning it's hard to justify its price tag
-
We're in the age of "mega-tasking," and here's what HP is doing about itnews The world's first ultrawide conferencing monitor and a Nvidia-powered workstation aim to tackle our growing work demands
-
The HP OmniBook X Flip 16 is a brilliant, big, beautiful 2-in-1 laptop – but it's also an absolute bargainReviews HP pairs a gorgeous OLED touchscreen with a smart 2-in-1 design – the result is a superb everyday laptop for sensible money
-
AI PCs are paying dividends for HP as firm reports sales surgeNews HP has pinned recent revenue increases on Windows 11 and AI PC sales
-
The HP OmniStudio X is a powerful, design-led all-in-one for creative work – but it could do with a stronger GPUReviews HP's answer to the iMac is a premium all-in-one that blends powerful performance with sleek design
-
HP Envy x360 2-in-1 (14-FC0009NA) review: A cut-price AI PC for the enterpriseReviews The Intel-powered HP Envy x360 is a decent punt for its price point despite a few bugbears