IT Pro is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

NYU calls for rework, not a repeal of Section 230

Report claims concerns over anti-conservative bias in big tech are unfounded

New York University (NYU) has published a report dismissing claims of anti-conservative bias among social media companies and warning the government to amend, rather than repeal, Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act.

The Center's deputy director Paul M Bennett and research fellow J. Grant Sims worked on the report, titled “False Accusation: The Unfounded Claim that Social Media Companies Censor Conservatives.” Evaluating claims of anti-conservative bias in social media groups, it highlighted several comments made by senators, TV presenters, and influencers, claiming social media companies were militarizing the information sphere and helped rig the election.

"The claim of anti-conservative animus on the part of social media companies is itself a form of disinformation: a falsehood with no reliable evidence to support it," the report says.

The researchers acknowledge claims of bias among big tech companies, including allegations that Facebook deliberately played down conservative stories in its Trending Topics section, and Google influenced search engine rankings to promote left-leaning content. However, it dismisses these claims, citing denials from the companies themselves, and, in some cases, quoting opposing research that refutes the allegations.

The report also suggests social media platforms actually facilitated the attack by right-wing activists on the Capital by not acting quickly enough. It also cites research finding supporters of former President Trump tended to spread "junk news" more readily than all the other groups evaluated.

Many commentators, including former President Trump himself, used the perceived bias as a talking point for repealing Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which protects online platforms from liability for what their users post there. President Joe Biden has also targeted the law, though it’s unclear whether this would include a full repeal or an amendment.

Instead, the NYU report calls for Congress to update Section 230, amending it to introduce new responsibilities around policing content. One such obligation could be to ensure that ranking and recommendation algorithms don't favor sensational material simply to fuel engagement, it said.

The report also suggests creating a Digital Regulatory Agency to help with this task. However, this agency wouldn’t interfere directly in content decisions and risk violating the First Amendment, it warned.

Other recommendations include greater disclosure for content moderation actions and offering users a choice of content moderation algorithms. Social media companies should devote more human moderation to influential accounts and pursue a constructive reform agenda for social media, it said. The latter would mean more cooperation between government and social media companies, even as the government pursues antitrust actions against Facebook and Google.

Featured Resources

What 2023 will mean for the industry

What do most IT decision makers really think will be the important trends and challenges in the coming year?

Free Download

2022 Magic quadrant for Security Information and Event Management (SIEM)

SIEM is evolving into a security platform with multiple features and deployment models

Free Download

IDC MarketScape: Worldwide unified endpoint management services

2022 vendor assessment

Free Download

Magic quadrant for application performance monitoring and observability

Enabling continuous updating of diverse & dynamic application environments

View Now

Recommended

CISA: Phishing campaign targeting US federal agencies went undetected for months
phishing

CISA: Phishing campaign targeting US federal agencies went undetected for months

26 Jan 2023
AWS splashes $35 billion to expand data centres in Virginia
data centres

AWS splashes $35 billion to expand data centres in Virginia

23 Jan 2023
Tech industry takes vast lead in green energy spending, biggest companies vie for top spot
Business strategy

Tech industry takes vast lead in green energy spending, biggest companies vie for top spot

19 Jan 2023
US 5G operators welcome new freedoms as FAA, airport concerns approach end
Policy & legislation

US 5G operators welcome new freedoms as FAA, airport concerns approach end

10 Jan 2023

Most Popular

Dutch hacker steals data from virtually entire population of Austria
data breaches

Dutch hacker steals data from virtually entire population of Austria

26 Jan 2023
GTA V vulnerability exposes PC users to partial remote code execution attacks
vulnerability

GTA V vulnerability exposes PC users to partial remote code execution attacks

23 Jan 2023
European partners expect growth this year, here are three ways they will achieve it
Sponsored

European partners expect growth this year, here are three ways they will achieve it

17 Jan 2023