IT Pro is supported by its audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Windows 8 vs Mac OS X Mountain Lion head-to-head review

A comprehensive look at the UI, software, security and business features to see which OS is top dog.

The Future

Equipping an office with computers means it's worth considering the future for your OS of choice. If you've bought Windows 8 then you're in luck: Microsoft won't be ending mainstream support until January 2018, and extended support won't run out until all the way in 2023 so you can safely use Windows 8 even though it will have been superseded by newer versions of the OS.

Apple will likely support Mountain Lion and Mavericks for many years to come, but Cupertino's locked-down approach means that you'll only be able to upgrade to later versions of OS X if your hardware's good enough. So when your colleagues are running a fully supported version of Windows 8 at the start of 2018 it's extremely unlikely that you'll be able to upgrade to the latest version of OS X.

Apple's software will continue to run smoothly on high-end hardware, but it also means that OS X-based machines will lag behind in just a few years. Microsoft's approach wins for business thanks to machines that can be maintained and supported for over a decade.

WINNER: Microsoft

Verdict

So it's 4 - 4 in the categories, but which OS do we pick as the overall winner?

Apple OS X has better apps, tighter security and works well on high-end hardware, so it's ideal for smaller businesses, sole traders, creative types and those don't need the corporate features served up by Microsoft. Windows still has the better UI, more versatility, enhanced business features, and longevity making it better for bigger medium and larger businesses.

We're quite capable of installing our own security software so we don't have to suffer with Microsoft Security Essentials and, when it comes to productivity, a copy of Office running on Windows is superior to the Mac alternative.

Windows pulls ahead in other important areas, too. Its business features lead the way, and Windows 8.1 irons out several of the issues we initially had with the UI while making the controversial Start screen more versatile and less intrusive.

OVERALL WINNER: Microsoft

Featured Resources

The 3D skills report

Add 3D skills to your creative toolkits and play a sizeable role in the digital future

Free Download

The increasing need for environmental intelligence solutions

How sustainability has become a major business priority and is continuing to grow in importance

Free Download

2022 State of the multi-cloud report

What are the biggest multi-cloud motivations for decision-makers, and what are the leading challenges

Free Download

Solve global challenges with machine learning

Tackling our word's hardest problems with ML

Free Download

Recommended

Apple issues patch for macOS security bypass vulnerability
Security

Apple issues patch for macOS security bypass vulnerability

20 Dec 2022
Apple issues fix for ‘actively exploited’ WebKit zero-day vulnerability
Security

Apple issues fix for ‘actively exploited’ WebKit zero-day vulnerability

14 Dec 2022
Apple steps up user security with end-to-end encryption for iCloud
encryption

Apple steps up user security with end-to-end encryption for iCloud

8 Dec 2022
Apple and AMD will both be 'major customers' of TSMC's new Arizona fabs
Hardware

Apple and AMD will both be 'major customers' of TSMC's new Arizona fabs

7 Dec 2022

Most Popular

What's powering Britain’s fibre broadband boom?
Network & Internet

What's powering Britain’s fibre broadband boom?

3 Feb 2023
Dutch hacker steals data from virtually entire population of Austria
data breaches

Dutch hacker steals data from virtually entire population of Austria

26 Jan 2023
Windows 10 users locked out of devices by unskippable Microsoft 365 advert
bugs

Windows 10 users locked out of devices by unskippable Microsoft 365 advert

3 Feb 2023