Larger monitors aren't all they're cracked up to be
It turns out that upping the size of your monitor brings complications along with the supposed benefits of a higher resolution
Every now and then, you may be asked – if you were to start a new job tomorrow – what’s the one piece of IT equipment you would want to be given? I’d probably answer that I’d want a 3:2 4K monitor that can pivot into portrait mode; so much of my work is done in multiple windows that my current 24in screen isn’t cutting it anymore.
Well, life moves fast. At the time of writing, I’ve got a 27in Quad HD, rotatable monitor sitting on my desk and, well, I kinda hate it.
Life was simple with my 24in Full HD screen. You could just about work on two documents side by side and everything scaled nicely. Things aren’t quite as peachy with those three extra inches. The bump in resolution to 2,560 x 1,440 is problematic. Yes, I’ve got more screen acreage to play with, but icons are tiny and text is often hard to read.
I’ve fiddled around with macOS’s scaling options, but I can’t get it right. If you drop down to 2,048 x 1,152 things look blurry; if you scale back to Full HD, everything looks out of proportion, like you’re sitting too close to the TV.
Some apps – and I stress the word ‘some’ – help you work around the small icons or text problem. I can scale both the user interface (UI) and the window of the brilliant Vivaldi browser independently, so everything is just the right size. Microsoft Word lets me easily zoom the page too, so I can read what I’m writing without pressing my nose to the glass.
Others refuse to be as accommodating. My email app, Spark, has no scaling options, making certain messages as hard to read as a Will Self novel. Likewise my calendar app, Cron, so don’t expect me at any press conferences for a while. Photoshop does have a modicum of UI scaling, although it doesn’t warn you that you need to restart Photoshop for it to take effect. Consequently, I spent ten minutes screaming “you haven’t done anything!” at my king-size screen before a YouTube video bailed me out.
I have a Windows 11 system connected to the monitor, too, and things are a little better there. The OS-level scaling options are equally ineffective, and the same small text/icon issues arise with certain apps, mainly those from smaller developers. I now spend my day craning my neck back and forth from the screen, depending on which app I’m using. I’m 98.6% certain you won’t find this recommended in any workplace health and safety manuals.
There are, of course, upsides to the big screen experience. It’s definitely easier to work with two, or even three, app windows side-by-side on the bigger screen. Windows 11 users may also see the new update gives it a major advantage over macOS now, because of the ease with which you can snap windows into fixed layouts. I had to download a third-party app (Magnet) to snap windows in macOS and it’s nowhere near as simple as it is in Windows.
As for the dream of effortlessly flipping the screen into portrait mode and working on my lengthy treatises without having to constantly scroll up and down? Well, that proved to be a washout. Firstly, the design of my desk makes rotating the screen all but impossible, not least because I normally have my MacBook Pro screen open beneath the monitor. Even if I bought a new desk, though, and shuffled the laptop to the side, it’s still no cakewalk to flip the monitor into portrait mode because of the power and display cables sprouting out of the back of the screen. You need a fair bit of slack in those cables to make rotating painless, which means juggling plugs under the desk and praying you don’t accidentally yank a display cable out in the process.
The moral of this tale? Be careful what you wish for. I’ll keep looking for apps that offer proper scaling and keep tweaking my desk setup to see if I can make things more comfortable, but shifting to a bigger screen has created as many problems as it’s solved. The assumption that bigger is better has proven to be woefully misguided. Like a politician offering excuses following a major cockup, I truly didn’t appreciate the scale of the problem.
2023 Strategic roadmap for data security platform convergence
Capitalise on your data and share it securely using consolidated platformsFree Download
The 3D trends report
Presenting one of the most exciting frontiers in visual cultureFree Download
The Total Economic Impact™ of IBM Cloud Pak® for Watson AIOps with Instana
Cost savings and business benefitsFree Download
Leverage automated APM to accelerate CI/CD and boost application performance
Constant change to meet fast-evolving application functionalityFree Download